Project Mimir discussion

Meditations: A New Translation (Modern Library)
This topic is about Meditations
18 views
Current Book > Negative Emotions and Stoic Philosophy

Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

John (johnbrock) | 18 comments From my understanding, one of the tenets of stoic philosophy is the reduction of negative feelings (anger, sadness, jealousy etc).

Are negative emotions important for our well being? Shouldn't we not be afraid to feel them?


message 2: by Bruce (last edited Feb 06, 2017 05:10PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Bruce (geeksaurus) | 3 comments It's not necessarily a reduction in negative feelings that the Stoics strive for. Rather, it's a reconceptualization of the world so that things wouldn't lead to negative feelings in the first place. Of course, it's impossible to be a Sage and everyone feels negative emotions. What a practitioner can do is recognize the negative feelings as "Impressions". We are not angry unless we think we are angry. If you feel anger, you can recognize it as a feeling, its presence, without it letting it get a foothold in your mind. (This technique of cognitive distancing is used in modern CBT)

So it doesn't seek out to reduce negative emotions. Negative emotions are not "bad" nor are positive emotions "good." They are neutral. Stoicism states that certain beliefs lead to negative emotions. The reduction in negative feelings is a consequence of adopting a certain set of beliefs; not a tenant of those beliefs.

The same goes for even positive emotions which can enthrall us in passion.


John (johnbrock) | 18 comments I'm going to need to reread A Guide to the Good Life.


Bruce (geeksaurus) | 3 comments It doesn't talk about this.


John (johnbrock) | 18 comments Bruce wrote: "It doesn't talk about this."
Curses!


back to top