23 Short Classics discussion

Silas Marner
This topic is about Silas Marner
21 views
July Read - Silas Marner by George Eliot

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Melissa (new)

Melissa Lenhardt (melissalenhardt) | 31 comments Mod
Okay, I totally dropped the ball in June. Silas Marner was the book but I didn't start a discussion group or change the status of the book. So, let's read this in July as well. I know I haven't read it, but I'm going to on vacation. For sure.


message 2: by Elsbeth (last edited Jul 03, 2014 11:11AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Elsbeth (elsbethgm) I didn't read this, yet, as well. So an extra month is fine by me!
I did have time to read our april-groupread... About time, isn't it! So, now I've read all previous 5 and I am ready for this one!

Have a nice vacation, Melissa!


Jonelle (joco) | 16 comments I'm having a hard time reading Silas Marner.
Doesn't help that I always read it at bedtime :-)
but it's still been a hard read for me.
Still interested in how it will end!


message 4: by Melissa (new)

Melissa Lenhardt (melissalenhardt) | 31 comments Mod
I started Silas Marner before this book club and had a hard time with it, too.


Jonelle (joco) | 16 comments Okay, after picking this up and putting it down multiple times, I finally finishes it! If you can make it to the point of Eppie's arrival (about 2/3 the way into it) you've got it made. I didn't want to put it down after that point, and it then ended all too soon!
I had difficulty with the language, and I'm usually pretty good with dialect. I think part of my frustration with and my original dislike for this book stemmed from the seeming unrelated story lines that just seemed like rabbit trails.
Eliot had a masterful way of just bringing them all together, drawing me in, and making me wish that it would keep going on! Kind of like my college experience! I just started to enjoy it when it was almost over! ;-)
Definitely was worthy of being in the 23 short classics list - just hang in there, baby!


Elsbeth (elsbethgm) I started it and than realized I read it a few years ago. So I put it away again, even though I can't really remember it that well. Just didn't feel like re-reading it right now.


message 7: by Melissa (new)

Melissa Lenhardt (melissalenhardt) | 31 comments Mod
Jonelle wins the award for being what looks like the only one of us to finish the book. Good for you!


Jonelle (joco) | 16 comments Okay, I have already forgotten names in the book, but suggest that everyone skip the first 2/3 of the book.
Go to the chapter where the rich guys wife tries to surprise him with his daughter (there's a big party going on). That is when it picked up. "Eppie" really changes Silas' life, and I think y'all would enjoy it from there!

What's the August book?


message 9: by Linda (new)

Linda (lulutp) | 4 comments Sorry that I forgot to post, but I read this book the month we were really supposed to read it! I enjoyed it, but mostly because my English teacher in 5th grade read it to us (along with other classics)


message 10: by Betsy (new)

Betsy  | 4 comments I bought the book but haven't started reading it yet. I have some time on my hands so I'm going to read it.


back to top