YA Book Addicts discussion
Book Talk (Series)
>
If I Stay
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Riya
(new)
Jul 26, 2014 05:09PM
Anyone else read this series? It's a completely unique idea, and it's an amazing one! Honestly one of my favorite books
reply
|
flag
I just finished this and am reading where she went now I love it
I'm not at the heartbreaking part yet but thanks for the warning I will prepare the tissues;)
Okay. Adams view is definitely intense. Things have changed so so much
I've only read the first book; it was absolutely amazing! Forman has a way with words, and I felt so connected with the characters--Mia, Kim, Adam, everyone <3 can't wait to read the sequel.
Connie wrote: "I've only read the first book; it was absolutely amazing! Forman has a way with words, and I felt so connected with the characters--Mia, Kim, Adam, everyone <3 can't wait to read the sequel."You'll love it!
I finished it! I loved it!! Their ending was good for a minute I thought they were going to breakup again
I loved the series!! If I Stay was probably my favorite, but yes, Where She Went was so heartbreaking!! But awesome. :)
I just finished If I Stay. It's beautifully written and I highly recommend it. Check out my review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Both of these books were beautifully written. In my oppionion I liked Where She Went better than If I Stay and I'm kinda sad that there not making a Where She Went movie :(
@ kaitlyn all her books are beautifully written
Caitlin: I wish they'd make a Where She Went movie! That would be awesome!Lauren: Its good to hear that all of her books are good. I was going to read her other ones but wasn't sure on their quality.
Ohmygosh I just saw the movie today, and even after reading the book I was not prepared for the level of Xtreme Sadness and waterworks that it procured from me. Awesome movie adaptation!!
The movie adaption was alright, but it focused more on the relationship between Mia and Adam in comparison to the book.. I'm not a fan of romance really. The book was great, i love reading sad books. I love it when I cry because of a book or movie, and this book and book adaption did that. :)
I just received my copy yesterday from the library after a month of waiting! I haven't started it yet, but I should be finished with it by the end of the week. Hopefully.
I only read the first book, but I loved how Forman used music throughout the book to sort of set the mood and carry the story.While reading it, I couldn't put it down and ended up staying awake until like 3 AM reading it.
I know, I loved how original she was while writing it, and the flashback style was really engrossing
I finished this book yesterday and I really liked the story, although her writing style it's not my favourite...
Should I read the sequel?
And did someone see the movie adaptation? How it was?
Should I read the sequel?
And did someone see the movie adaptation? How it was?
I read this book for 2 days and I loved Gayle Forman's style of writing. I also liked the story because it was something different and it gives you some things to think about.Where she went is also a great book !
This had to be one of the greatest books I've read in a long time. it had a unique, interesting concept. I really enjoyed it because it had a girl talking about death and thinking about what comes next without it being about cancer. Nowadays there seem to be a lot of cancer books going around in YA literature and it was a refreshing break to get a serious, and sad book without it being about cancer. Thank you Gayle Forman.
Just finished the first and got the second! So great. Seriously, though. I loved it.









