2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #1 discussion

Felix Decker requests Frank Malloy’s help in investigating Chilton Devries’ apparent murder. Why Frank?

I had no idea why he wanted Frank to do it even by the end of the book. There was something about it being a test but I didn't understand what it was a test for!

I think the main reason he chose Frank is because he knows him from previous investigations. How many cops would a rich guy like Felix Decker actually know? Now that Teddy Roosevelt is no longer the commissioner, I'm not sure how much pull Mr. Decker would have with the police force.

Felix is a complicated man and I believe he asked for Frank because he’s proven to be a skilled investigator. He wanted someone to look into Devries death but also wanted to keep it quiet. Frank had already demonstrated he could be discreet. But, this was different. He let Frank inside his world more than he probably wanted.

I’m not sure of the test either. Frank did what Felix asked without passing judgment at every juncture. He didn’t steal anything, accept any bribes nor did he manhandle anyone, all behaviors considered norms for the NYPD.

Were these the tests? Maybe. But somehow, Felix may have more up his sleeves.

My own thought was that the test was to take Frank's measure, as a man and as a cop. He knows Frank is important to Sarah, that she trusts him. Felix wants to know if he's worthy of that trust.

The point that he's also probably the only detective he knows is also a good one. :-)

Great points, Veronica! I’m sure Felix was sizing up the man and the cop. I’m not so sure he’s ready to accept him as a son-in-law but he certainly is feeling more comfortable with their friendship.

I'm with Veronica with this one as well. I'm not sure Felix was all that interested in justice. He wanted Frank to prove himself worthy.