2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #1 discussion

When they find Rose, she’s also unwilling to be forthcoming with her family about what happened. Did you expect her to react this way? At any time during the story, did you suspect her of killing Milo?

I assumed she was ashamed to tell her family but then she ran home to them!!! And yes she was my number one suspect after Sarah found there was just a bolt on the cage.

Her sister-in-law was just wonderful and I think Rose felt comfortable enough to at least rejoin them. I was glad when she finally let her help.

I suspected Rose up until she said she needed to see Grace and I figured she was going to tell her she didn’t do it.

For whatever reason, I did not suspect Rose. I always thought that a male killed Milo.

Just like Phrynne, I thought she might be the killer when we learned that her cage in the cellar was easy to unbolt. I'm not sure when I changed my mind and thought it was Joanna.

Another great red herring 😍

Rose was lucky in that she felt able to return home. I think she knew Franchesca would welcome her back wholeheartedly.

I only began to suspect her when Grace spoke to Sarah and said to tell Rose she didn't remember. This was very short-lived though.