The Witch Elm discussion

I read her very first book and now her latest book and I don't think I will read anymore. At first you are very drawn in and excited and interested then you are bored and it gets very repetitive and she spells things out for you so you want to yell YA I KNOW I FIGURED THAT out. The characters are unlikeable and there is little resolution that you even care about. But hey let me know if there is one of her books you loved and I will check it out and hopefully change my mind. Currently, I am not a fan

I loved all six of her Dublin Murder series, but The Witch Elm did not, in the end - and because of the last sixth - work for me.

Try Faithful Place. Great characters, story and sense of place. Her best book, imo.

I liked it a lot and couldn't put it down. That is, up until the last part before the end. It's what we waited for, yet it felt like someone else had written that part. It didn't ring true for me. However, I did like Toby, and I thought his outcome was fair.