Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

https://www.goodreads.com/work/editio...

Seems to be a fan-merge of books 4 and 5 of A Song of Ice and Fire. I'm not sure if this should be here (but I don't think so).

It's not on WorldCat or on the list of Random House George R.R. Martin books, that I could see.

bump

It is indeed a fan merge. It requires answering a question "Do you own the actual books?" before reading their PDF mashup, supposedly in their opinion to avoid copyright infringement.

bump

IMO, that is not a book by GR standards. Given the number of adds (544 and 34), I suggest tossing this one to Support for their take on it.

One of the reviews says right out it's a "fanmade chronological cut."

So what do you think, merge them into book 4? Seems reasonable to me.

Maybe book 5 since the reviews would encompass both.

I am not especially knowledgeable about this series. When this thread was first posted, I did some searches, and at least one site claimed there was a limited-edition ebook edition of this released by the author. If that is definitely not true, then I would agree this should be merged -- probably into the earlier book.

rivka wrote: "If that is definitely not true, then I would agree this should be merged -- probably into the earlier book."

I have also researched more and I do not think this was ever released. I think the fans have merged it themselves. I have now merged the book into A Feast for Crows.