The Light Between Oceans discussion

I haven't read The Bone People but I recall The Light Between Oceans having a moral dilemma and not necessarily finding myself in agreement with the character’s choices.

Travelin wrote: "From this book's description, the story of the shipwrecked boy and someone living in a kind of lighthouse sounds like "The Bone People", about New Zealand. That was a terrible book about terrible s..."
There is a moral dillemma... and I also was not comfortable with the solution.

Now I'll have to read the Bone People again.