I'm Definitely a Madman With a Box discussion

What did you think of it?

Okay so I just finished this episode like literally 5 minutes ago and I loved it. I loved the part where he said "I'm not a good man and I'm not a bad man, I'm an idiot!" and I also loved how Danny still loved Clara even though he was a cyber man. I hated how the girl with the bow tie and asthma died right after the Doctor asked he to travel with him, I really wanted her to next companion. I also liked how Danny let the kid come back to life instead of himself and I cried when Clara told the Doctor how happy she and Danny would be. I kinda don't really want the Doctor to go back to Gallifray because that would sorta end Doctor Who wouldn't it? The last of the time lords bent on saving the universe because he had to kill his people didn't really kill his people and spent the last what 1200 years redeeming himself? Just my opinion. I'm pretty excited for the Christmas episode though.

That part when he says he's a not a good man scared me, but once he said he's a bad man I was fine. He's both, that was his point. I cried so hard throughout this whole episode. I loved the sendoff with the Brigadier, he was my favorite companion and that was perfect. I was upset that Missy killed Osgood, but now I think about it, her "zapper" was probably just a teleport. As for Gallifrey, who knows if he found it or not. But, it wouldn't end it, the classic series had several episodes back on Gallifrey (that was before the time war). But I give this episode a 10/10.

I sincerely hope that Osgood wasn't killed ( I thought about the zapper thing too like how in one of the earlier exposes with 10 the dalek's zapped Rose and the Doctor thought she died but she didn't right?) and if she is still alive, I really do hope she's a companion or at least makes more appearances in the show.

Hear, hear. That's what I thought when the Doctor told her about "all of time and space".

Yes!! Missy picked up on that and that's why she killed her and I saw it coming as soon as the Doctor said it to her but I feel like she can't be dead because he said that and he didn't mourn and he death was so predictable and sudden. I just really hope she's not dead.

We'll see what happens, meanwhile we can wait for the Christmas special. Have you seen next time trailer?

Yes! The one with Santa? XD I'm psyched for that episode.

Same here! Remember when the Doctor mentioned Santa as "Jeff" back in the Christmas Carol?

Haha I do!

I've had this theory for a while...you know Santa travels in one night to deliver presents, so Santa must be a Time Lord!