2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

Robin and Will’s relationship fractured when he questioned whether she’d slept with Theodore Glenn. Was she right in walking away from him? Do you think his judgment was based on her being a stripper, Glenn’s history or a bit of both?

I feel like he had a right to ask the question since the other victims had been previous girlfriends, but he could have approached it better since I believe Robin has stated before that the hadn't been in any kind of relationship with Glenn.

She walked away from him after he asked her for the second time. I really don't blame her. He had the right to ask her based on the fact that all the others had slept with Glenn. However, he should have believed her and not questioned her again. He obviously didn't believe her the first time. I think his judgment was based partly on Glenn's history but also that she was a stripper.

It was how he asked the question the second time, as if he didn’t believe her. In that moment, she felt her being a stripper would always be between them and she walked away. It was about trust and he showed her he didn’t trust her. She was right to walk away, which had him really experience the loss and caused him to reflect on his feelings.

Agreed: in the first instance, he had to clarify because he was a law officer; in the second, he was an idiot.

😆😆😆