Black Ice Black Ice discussion


121 views
SPOILER ALERT* Calvin..........

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Nirvana (last edited Dec 27, 2014 12:16PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nirvana If you didn't read this book, get out of here :)
-I really want to ask if someone else already knew about who was the murderer, before of Britt discovered it.
I mean it was a little obvious, I think.


Lili Todd *murderer


AbigailDenyse01 I had my suspicions. I honestly never thought it was that other dude. that would be way to easy. so I thought who else could it be? I knew it wasn't jude. so it was only likely that it was calvin.


message 4: by Belle (new) - added it

Belle It was Calivin indeed, Jude was too cute to even suspect such a thing from


Imani Because I knew it was going to be unexpected I guessed Calvin but at one point I did suspect Shaun!


message 6: by Belle (new) - added it

Belle i noie right... it was that cowboy at clue


Cassie    'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood I didn't even expect it to be Calivin. I thought for sure it was Shaun. Because come on! With the cowboy thing at the beginning and then all that. I just assumed it was him! Plus you don't see a lot of him until like half way to the end. And a little in the first few chapters. But that's it! Although I did think it was Jude only a few times because he seemed a little to trusting and then he's switch and stuff..


Katelyn I suspected Shaun in the beginning but after Clavin killed Shaun and maybe even before that I totally guessed he was the killer.


Athena Milbert I thought it was Shaun... I'm such a sucker for red herrings. But I knew it couldn't possibly be Jude, despite what Britt thought when she wasn't drunk on moonshine.


Karen Katelyn wrote: "I suspected Shaun in the beginning but after Clavin killed Shaun and maybe even before that I totally guessed he was the killer."

Me too. Después de eso supe que escondía algo turbio, para mi fue muy obvio que no estaba bien de la cabeza.


back to top