Harry Potter discussion

Anyone read this book yet? Is it one you would recommend others to purchase?

Which one the 7th one?

I've got a review up of it here on GRs. It's a boook Kayla from Mugglenet.com. Parts of the book are good. Parts are just stupid.

There is another thread in this group that already discussed this book.

http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1...

I heard about this book form Mugglecast, th podcast of Mugglenet. But I haven't read it yet.

I haven't read it...i want too...even though I don't think Harry should die.

Well, it's more of reasons why he should have, like all the odds against him and such, etc. I think. I believe there may be other topics in the book too, but I'm not sure.

Have any of you actually read a description of this book or looked at it? It's got over 30 topics, with the title just being one of them. They give the arguements for and against each question, then very briefly give you their opinion as to which they agree with. Some questions are so stupid, like who would you rather kiss... a dementor or Lord Voldemort. Other questions posed are more interesting like who helped Harry more throughout the series... Ron or Hermoine?

I was in a bookstore the other day and ran across the book. I quickly glanced through it and it looked promising but I didn't want to purchase it and realize it didn't have anything really new that was not already discussed. Thanks for the review Briansgirl

Your welcome.
I bought it because I havn't discussed it on the various online forums. So it was interesting to me. Well, some of it. I could really care less about the debate on which would you rather do... give Voldemort a foot massage or shave Hagrid's back. Other the other hand, I was curious as to their take on wether Harry should have died and wether JKR should have revealed Dumbledore's sexual orientation.

Harry should dead is impossible,but i want to know what's the book writing?

Harry should have died. It makes no sense that he lived. If the part of the Voldamort's soul in Harry truely left, then Harry must have been fully dead, right? Besides, Harry shouldn't get everything he wants.

Never heard of it before.

heh, if he died how is the book continue?

And the end of book 7 you dope. If y'all don't have a clue about the book in question being debated, please at least check out a review first before commenting. Otherwise you just make yourself look like an idiot.

Mugglenet.com's Harry Potter Should Have Died Controversial Views from the #1 Fan Site

Yeah shen. It gives reason onwhy it doesn't make sense how Harry survived everhting. Anyways JKR couldv'e had Harry die at anytime... Therefore ending the series, it wouldn't continue.

For all we know, she was planning on killing him, but thought that would disappoint certain readers. Besides, he didn't get everything he wanted. I don't think he wanted Lupin, Fred, Tonks, and all those other people to die.

Brenda wrote: "I was in a bookstore the other day and ran across the book. I quickly glanced through it and it looked promising but I didn't want to purchase it and realize it didn't have anything really new tha..."

cool.

JKR planned out her epilogue in the beginning. I think she always intended Harry to live.

of course, he's the boy who lived. he has to LIVE.

Still, he didn't get everything he wanted.

I know.

I agree, as always.