Never Never question

Shrimp would be my guess to, but honestly i think there is sth more than some girl who made this, i hope it's gonna be big and romantic

Or maybe Avril, but my #1 suspect is shrimp girl too.

Ezra has a huge role in it.. we just don't know how yet.. that's my guess~

I think it has something to do with the dream Charlie had. The building w/blacked out windows had bottles, bones, etc (voodoo). The voodoo woman had a picture of the same gate in her store and the guy said it was the first time he had seen it but the lady said they're here for me (like she knew them). I think it's some kind of curse on them and all the clues will lead them back to their lives BEFORE the court case and their families hating each other. Back to true love.

I think the shrimp girl may be a clue but I don't think it's all her.

I definitely think Shrimp is part of it, but there are going to be three books so I'm sure there will be a big twist in the next two. Shrimp seems too easy of a guess to know what's going on.

I hope they go back to the tarot reader and get more information, as well as let Landon in. If they talk with him about it he can fill in SO many more gaps of their history.

While I was reading, I started wondering if it had something to do with their fathers court case? His dad mentioned something about him having to testify? (But then I realised that both court cases are over, aren't they? so that would make my theory moot.)
I kind of hope shrimp doesn't have anything to do with it - it would be too predictable and not twisty enough for me.

Shrimp girl is definitely involved somehow. But I don't think it's solely her either. And the tarot card reader? I thought she was going to be able to tell them what was going on (when I still didn't know the series would continue). I think there could still be answer the tarot card reader can reveal. And Logan! I so wanted Silas to trust in him! Brian, I feel like there's something with him, it's just bugging me because everything happened the same weekend Silas punched Brian's dad. And Brian kept bugging Charlie, which made me want to punch him too!

But then again, that'd just be too obvious. I love these kinds of stories that make you think! :D

If the last book of the trilogy provides a logical (rather than paranormal) solution, it could be easily explained that Charlie and Silas were given a post hypnotic suggestion to simulate amnesia at 11:00 am every other day.

An important clue is the photo of the broken gate on Charlie's wall and in the Tarot Store.

I think it is the Shrimp girl. Maybe she sees trouble between the two of them and she wants to help them. The only way to break the curse is that both of them have to find within themselves to work things out within that small window of time.

OMG! I cannot wait for the second part!

I kind of don't think Brian or Shrimp are going to be behind all this.I definitely think the gate picture has a connection though!

I think the Shrimp girl has some info on what's going on, but I also think this has something to do with the 2 dads.

What if it's something like in Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind?.. I mean they are always asking why they were together etc.
We need answers! :P

Maybe this is sci-fi lol, likely not but their brains could've altered.