Ranters and Reviewers discussion

Was this horrible or a guilty pleasure?

SJM Trash wrote: "Well the first book wasn’t great but I liked the other two. Minus the sex scenes."

I heard something about floating in the sky and I ran far, far away

SJM Trash wrote: "How do you have sex while flying? And not in an airplane because I understand that. But because one of you has wings."

Umm... I don't even know. I think they crashed into the roof of a house... while doing it. They had better pay that family

Oh, and there's also velvet-wrapped steel, don't forget

SJM Trash wrote: "No no no. They almost crashed.
And oh god."

Thank God. Can you imagine looking up...

Is it a bird?
Is it a plane?
No, it's two fae banging

I'm pretty sure that's a quote from a Cindy video

😂cindy's videos are the best

and I'm definitely not reading acotar anytime soon 😂 it's probably not very appropriate for my age (then again i know someone who read it who's my age) but honestly it doesn't sound very interesting

honestly I don't understand why these books are categorised into YA Fantasy instead of Adult fantasy –_–

same T=T

i rated the first book 2 stars honestly just because i semi enjoyed the climax sith the alaskan bull worm and such, but acomaf got 1 STAR, and it's the highest rated book on gr i've ever read... yeah, no, definitely not continuing. i was expecting a really good fantasy bc everyone kept raving but i will NEVER be reading sarah j mass AGAIN... someone should have told me it was adult :(

poor 13 yo me will forever be scarred by that scene and the bad writing

ReLiz ⚡️ wrote: "I had this on my TBR but then I heard about all the cringy sex scenes and I was like...not worth it. I want to read fantasy, not explict romance.

And who the heck does it in the sky?? Like if some..."

Exactly my thoughts

OMG SO TRUE!!!

I mean, I liked the second and third and I've yet to read the fourth.
But I also think that people really don't know the age range for YA. It's around 17. So people keep saying that this should be adult/new adult, but really you shouldn't be reading YA if you're not okay with a little bit of smut, or at least intense kissing.

Evie wrote: "I mean, I liked the second and third and I've yet to read the fourth.
But I also think that people really don't know the age range for YA. It's around 17. So people keep saying that this should be ..."

I always thought YA was ages 13 through 18 or something.

13 through 17 I'd say...which I think is actually a large gap. A 13 year old and 17 year old (typically) aren't going to want to read the same books. I think I watched a Booktube video that argues this.

Sofia wrote: "Evie wrote: "I mean, I liked the second and third and I've yet to read the fourth.
But I also think that people really don't know the age range for YA. It's around 17. So people keep saying that th..."

I think maybe it's 14-17/18.
I don't know, but I do know that ACOTAR is older YA.
Banging in the sky?
Really?

Please don't mention the sky banging. *scarred*

hello people who have read this book.
if i bought a copy of it and my dad skimmed through it a bit, would he find pages upon pages of sex scenes or is there only a little bit? My dad usually just looks through my books in like 20 seconds for some reason and I don't want him to open to a random smut page-

DragonWithHeels wrote: "hello people who have read this book.
if i bought a copy of it and my dad skimmed through it a bit, would he find pages upon pages of sex scenes or is there only a little bit? My dad usually just l..."

The first book isn't so bad. The second book is considerably worse. The third book is... bad. ACOSF apparently has graphic sex every eight pages.

I agree with Sofia. The first book is actually pretty good, I loved the fantasy concepts. Now the second takes a huge turn for smutty real quick (which apparently I enjoyed a few years ago though ahah).... As for the third book I only watched booktubers make fun of it (most specifically Cindy), so I won't be the best judge of character.

Sofia wrote: "SJM Trash wrote: "No no no. They almost crashed.
And oh god."

Thank God. Can you imagine looking up...

Is it a bird?
Is it a plane?
No, it's two fae banging

lol!!

I'm pretty sure that's a quote from..."

Sofia wrote: "SJM Trash wrote: "No no no. They almost crashed.
And oh god."

Thank God. Can you imagine looking up...

Is it a bird?
Is it a plane?
No, it's two fae banging

I'm pretty sure that's a quote from..."

I’m not a fan of this series.
I have a lot of reasons as to why I didn’t like it, but I respect others opinions. I can totally see why so many people love it. :)

ACOMAF and ACOWAR were good. The first book and novella weren’t as great. I haven’t read ACOSF yet, just because Nesta wasn’t my favorite character. She was practically an antagonist to Feyre so not sure about a whole book just with her, although I liked Cassian. ToG is so much better than ACOTAR though IMO.