2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

The killer referred to herself as Atropos, one of the three Fates. Who was on your list of suspects until she was revealed to be Amanda? Were you surprised to learn it was her?

I actually suspected Hannah after Amanda's accident and was surprised at the revelation.

Personally, I actually think the story would have been better, more realistic and more suspenseful if Caitlyn's alter ego, Kelly, had been the killer. That said, I knew she would not be because of the romance angle to the book.

I didn't have a clue that it was Amanda. I knew it wasn't Caitlyn/Kelly. I thought it might be Hannah or one of the Biscayne's. I can't remember her name, (the one who Copper worried about disappearing all the time) was my top suspect.

Amanda, from the beginning. Caitlyn/Kelly and Hannah were to young to have killed either Charles or Cameron.

Lauren wrote: "I actually suspected Hannah after Amanda's accident and was surprised at the revelation.

Personally, I actually think the story would have been better, more realistic and more suspenseful if Cait..."

Yes, Lauren. My thoughts exactly!

Anita, hats off to you because Amanda was never on my list. In fact, I thought her to be the most normal in this crazy family.

I thought Hannah was too young to have killed Charles and exploded the boat where Kelly died. I didn’t know the crazy aunt was dead and thought it was her. There was a time I thought alter-identity Kelly was the murderer but then when she started planning Caitlyn’s demise, that didn’t make sense. But then I thought maybe she was going to kill her off metaphorically by not allowing her to come out again.

It gave me a brain cramp.

Brain cramps. I like that.

I had to just let go and wait to find out.

Jonetta wrote: "Anita, hats off to you because Amanda was never on my list. In fact, I thought her to be the most normal in this crazy family.

I thought Hannah was too young to have killed Charles and exploded t..."

I agree with Jonetta here and I also like the "brain cramps" comment.

At first, I thought it was someone we hadn't met before - maybe Griffin's mother? But that was just me trying to be creative, lol. I then thought maybe Kelly, but once the MPD was revealed, I knew it couldn't be her. Hannah was on my list of suspects for a while, and right up until the end, I thought it was her.

I suppose Caitlyn/Kelly would have been more interesting; but I liked Caitlyn and really felt for her, so I didn't want it to me her. Plus, even though I didn't like Adam, I wanted her to have a happy ending. Yes, her ending was fluffy and unrealistic, but I'm just a happy ending type of person, even if it is unbelievable.

Hannah I like a good happy ending too.