2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

When Andrew determined that Peter Caldwell was not buried with a stuffed animal, Max and Lucy were convinced he wasn’t murdered by their killer and they both believed Blair was guilty of the crime. Were you convinced in this moment or even earlier?

I believed she was the murderer before this reveal, but not finding a stuffed toy put the nail in her coffin for me.

I had my doubts earlier. All the other victims were in California, Scottsdale, AZ was another divination from the other murders.

As the investigation progressed and Blair pressed John to stop Max, I could only conclude she had something to hide. Let’s face it. The prosecutor had something in order to bring her to trial and Blair’s attorney wouldn’t share that with Max. I was already convinced.

When we learned that Peter did not have a favorite toy buried with him, I was sure that Blair was the killer.

Good catch, Anita. I didn't even think about the fact that all of the murders were in California except this one.

Great catch!

That geography didn't hit me, particularly, either. I was sure Blair had done it after the detail about the toy came to light via Andrew, and I suspected earlier.

It's hard to move to another state and relearn a different state legal system. She wouldn't have made as much money if she left California.

I was convinced at this point. I was in denial, I guess, since I couldn't find a reason for her killing him.