Debates discussion

Which is better? LOTR movie or the books? Do you think they casted the movie correctly? Do you think it follows the book? Which was more captivating? annd DID you even read the full series? Cuz um...I didn't haha

Movie. No it doesn't that well. I have read the whole series.

I read all the books and watched all the movies. Honestly, the books are really good, but very descriptive. I think I might like the movies more. I defiantly think the casting was great.

I literally can't decide WHY WOULD YOU MAKE A DIE-HARD TOLKIEN FAN DECIDE??????????? The books (yes, I've read the entire series), make me cry over and over again the whole way through because they're so beautiful. But I like medieval war movies. So of course, I LOVE THE MOVIES SOOO MUCH!!!!!! Casting was perf, guys. Perf.

The books! It was actually The Hobbit movies that got me into the books, but the books are definitely better!

Denali wrote: "I literally can't decide WHY WOULD YOU MAKE A DIE-HARD TOLKIEN FAN DECIDE??????????? The books (yes, I've read the entire series), make me cry over and over again the whole way through because they..."

hahah becuz that's what I do to people >:)

I think that the movies were better. I guess cuz the books didn't hold my interest at much. :\

tbh, i've only seen the movies

BUT THEY WERE AMAZINGGGGGG!!!!!!

<333 legolas

Oof, okay. . . fine. I'll decide.
. . . . . . . . . the MOVIES!! (why did I have to decide!?)
And yes, the casting was amazing. Absolute perfection, ;)

✨ava✨ wrote: "<333 legolas"

<3!!

✨ava✨ wrote: "<333 legolas"

i mean he's freakin' amazing

I like Legolas and Frodo. And Merry and Pippin.

LEEGOOLLASSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
But also Aragorn.
ARAGORN!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Okay and now I'm fangirling not debating.
But isn't that what we're all doing??? XD

Pretty much. I mean how can you not fangirl when talking about LOTR?

Legolas and Merry all the way. Also Sam, obviously.

Casting was perfection

SO RIGHT, Kaylee!!!!

Wow, I didn't really think that people would actually debate about this XD

Hahahahaha

Denali wrote: "LEEGOOLLASSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
But also Aragorn.
ARAGORN!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Okay and now I'm fangirling not debating.
But isn't that what we're all doing??? XD"

Yes to Legolas
Yes to Aragorn
Yes to fangirling
And yes that's what we're all doing... how can you not fangirl when you're talking about Lord of the Rings? Like is it actually possible?