Book-a-book of the Month Club discussion

What If?: Serious Scientific Answers to Absurd Hypothetical Questions
This topic is about What If?
8 views
What If? > First Impressions - What If?

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
I see that several people are already reading this - so I thought I should get the discussion going a little early!

What are your first impressions of this book?


Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
For weeks this was available at my library . . . now that it is time to start reading it, I had to put in on hold! I hope I don't have to wait too long.


message 3: by Alex (new)

Alex (necrotic_flesh) | 122 comments I am going to the bookshop on Wednesday for this haha


Penny (pennydonovan) Matthew, I got it for free with Kindle Unlimited.


Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
Cool, Penny! Glad they had it for free - I have been avoiding Kindle Unlimited because of the subscription fee. Usually the library (both the physical one and their digital download site) is pretty reliable so I can save a few bucks. Every once in awhile it gets tough, though.

One thing I have been trying to avoid with this club is picking titles that are too new or super hot so that everyone doesn't have trouble finding them without spending money!


Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
Ugh - the waiting game continues. I get jealous everytime I see that one of you has started reading this book!


message 7: by Alex (new)

Alex (necrotic_flesh) | 122 comments bookshop didnt have it :( bought it from kobo. . . just not the same haha


Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
Yes! Finally came in!


Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
So far so good - actually much more science than humor, which was a little unexpected. But, still funny!


message 10: by Vicki Willis (new)

Vicki Willis I got the sample from Kindle and thought it was very interesting (and very scientific). I had to really pay attention for some parts and I thought my head was going to explode.
I decided not to buy it right now because it was too much thinking for me, but I may get it for my son's birthday. He likes that kind of thing. Then I can just read one a week or something.


Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
I agree Vicki - much more scientific than I was expecting.


Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
Just finish the two about draining our oceans and adding the water to Mars. I thought these were pretty cool!


message 13: by Joe (new)

Joe Imhoff | 168 comments Uh, I may be more nerdy than most of you. I've actually found the book to be quite humorous. Mostly because I like thinking about all the crazy stuff he's talking about.

The book has indeed been much more science than not.


message 14: by Penny (last edited Mar 28, 2015 08:07AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Penny (pennydonovan) This is pretty much what I expected it to be. I sometimes read the xkcd website, so I'm familiar with Randall Munroe's work. So far, I think it's pretty interesting.


Matthew (funkygman007) | 2945 comments Mod
Don't get me wrong, I thought it was generally funny and interesting - but I got a little lost on a few and some of the humor felt forced. So, I guess I am in the middle.

I think I tended to like the less scientific/mathematic/physics based ones, not because I don't like that stuff, but because the ones without it fit my like of random trivia better (i.e. the flyover state chapter)


back to top