midnight readers discussion

534 views
books!! > overrated author?

Comments Showing 1-50 of 56 (56 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Emma (new)

Emma Sedgwick | 54 comments Mod
who is an author that you think is overrated??


message 2: by kaden (new)

kaden | 10 comments emily henry


message 3: by kalia (new)

kalia | 1 comments Colleen hoover


message 4: by Ella⟢ (new)

Ella⟢ | 29 comments ^^Agreed, Colleen Hoover


message 5: by Kaya :) (new)

Kaya :) | 8 comments Colleen Hoover


yiyi ʕノ•ᴥ•ʔノ | 6 comments colleen hoover but like also sarah j mass


message 7: by Carly (last edited Nov 21, 2022 01:54PM) (new)

Carly (carlystach) | 27 comments Yiyi wrote: "colleen hoover but like also sarah j mass"

true about SJM. I like her books, but I can't say they're good. Personal enjoyment and quality are different things


message 8: by Carly (last edited Nov 22, 2022 12:03AM) (new)

Carly (carlystach) | 27 comments Reagan wrote: "SHM kinda went down hill after her first series tho"

I feel the quality has been consistent. Note, I didn't say consistently good. Aelin has this problem when no matter how big the bad guy is she just happens to find a new level to her power. Very much mary-sue energy. The parts where her secret scheme to solve all their problems is revealed at the very last second reads very deus ex machina to me.
I will say the monsters in the ToG series did seriously unnerve me for years. Well done. I also loved Manon and the concept of the witches. Her series have aspects that are really cool ideas and resonate with readers. That's why they're so popular, but there is a lot to be desired.


message 9: by c (new)

c w | 1 comments stephen king


message 10: by edie (new)

edie (cabaretofghosts) | 2 comments colleen hoover


message 11: by emmi (new)

emmi colleen hoover. did i like it ends with us? yes. is she still overrated? obviously.


message 12: by maria (new)

maria colleen hoover


message 13: by miri (new)

miri ❤︎ | 3 comments colleen hoover


message 14: by Diane (new)

Diane Reeves (dianereeves) | 1 comments Colleen Hoover and Nicholas Sparks


message 15: by Syraia (new)

Syraia LaPan | 5 comments Colleen Hoover


message 16: by Lens (new)

Lens PG | 1 comments Colleen Hoover obviously


message 17: by zoë ⋆。°✩ (new)

zoë ⋆。°✩ | 4 comments stephan king


message 18: by M ☾ (new)

M ☾ (mias_libraryy) SHM and Colleen Hoover


message 19: by Shelby (new)

Shelby Trautman | 2 comments Colleen Hoover and Stephen King


message 20: by Suraiya (new)

Suraiya | 4 comments No doubt Colleen Hoover


message 21: by kate (new)

kate | 7 comments Colleen Hoover


message 22: by Mindy (new)

Mindy | 3 comments Definitely Colleen Hoover. I know I’m not unique in my opinion, but it’s because it’s kind of crazy how popular her books are.


message 23: by BookOwl (new)

BookOwl | 5 comments Colleen Hoover, Veronica Roth and Sarah J. Mass


message 24: by BookOwl (new)

BookOwl | 5 comments Oh, and G.R.R. Martin… but i think that’s because his editor secretly quit in despair.


message 25: by hayat (new)

hayat | 1 comments HAHA i was gonna say colleen hoover but it looks like a lot of people are in agreement


message 26: by Jagoda (new)

Jagoda | 2 comments Im from poland so there’s this author called Weronika Malczak. She wrote a series on wattpad called “Rodzina Monet” (“Monet Family”) and now all the 10-14 year olds in Poland are reading it. It’s really toxic, full of things that aren’t for children and gives them bad idea of how the world should look. Oh and also justifies verbal assault and abuse as a form of “being just anxious about someone”.


message 27: by lara (new)

lara | 3 comments Colleen Hoover


message 28: by Shelby (new)

Shelby Trautman | 2 comments Stephen king fs


message 29: by Eva (new)

Eva Papaconstantinou | 10 comments Collen Hoover


message 30: by sam (new)

sam (sakurasam) | 2 comments shannon messenger- kotlc is absolutely terrible (pls dont take personally this is jut my opinions :D)


message 31: by hads (new)

hads (hadleykittymeow) Colleen Hoover and Stephen King
both problematic
coho shouldn’t even be allowed to publish books


message 32: by Tayjah (new)

Tayjah Ali Hazelwood


message 33: by Tayjah (new)

Tayjah Sally Rooney


message 34: by nina the orca (new)

nina the orca | 29 comments Colleen Hoover, Ali Hazelwood

CoHo’s books are alright and I know she’s rlly controversial so

Hazelwood’s are good, but way to overhyped

I think both these authors just copy their own books to much


message 35: by nina the orca (new)

nina the orca | 29 comments Tahereh Mafi too I feel is overhyped


message 36: by Joshua (new)

Joshua Vides | 7 comments Charles Dickens


message 37: by Mitesh (new)

Mitesh (miteshreads) | 5 comments c wrote: "stephen king"

seriously you think that Stphen King is overrated ?


message 38: by w.izt (new)

w.izt | 5 comments colleen hoover fs, she does the same thing over and over again and he fans will call it one of a kind and outstanding. idm her books but she’s overhyped


message 39: by Emma (new)

Emma Jay | 1 comments steven king 🥸


message 40: by brianna ♱ (new)

brianna ♱ (effortlesslyifeeleverything) colleen hoover 👀


message 41: by Ari (new)

Ari (arisxbooks) | 2 comments Colleen Hoover
i still wanna read more of her though just to see if her other books are any better


message 42: by hads (new)

hads (hadleykittymeow) colleen hoover, lynn painter


message 43: by Luc (new)

Luc | 2 comments colleen hoover. i’ve read a chapter and a half and WHAT. in gods name is that 😭😭😭


message 44: by Makaylynn (new)

Makaylynn Morgan | 1 comments Collen hoover


message 45: by Torono (new)

Torono (mrtorono) James Patterson for sure, I’ve read some of his work and it’s all extremely bland


message 46: by Torono (new)

Torono (mrtorono) James Patterson for sure, I’ve read some of his work and it’s all extremely bland


message 47: by Kara1086 (new)

Kara1086 Slaughter | 1 comments Stephanie Garber


message 48: by Noémie (new)

Noémie collen hoover, jk rowling, marion zimmer bradley


message 49: by mak ⊹₊⋆ (new)

mak ⊹₊⋆ (maklacedwithlove) | 1 comments coho and jlb and natasha preston


message 50: by Adelaide (new)

Adelaide | 11 comments Colleen Hoover- I see her books everywhere ToT


« previous 1
back to top