Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

97 views
[Closed] Added Books/Editions > (Open) Please add: ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ (1-9 จบ)

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Nino (last edited Jul 19, 2024 05:27AM) (new)

Nino (novemberincanada) | 74 comments * Title: ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ (1-9 จบ)
* Author(s) name(s): Oyuki Konno (Story), Satoru Nagasawa (Illustrations), ธิติมา (Translator)
* ISBN: 9789742575632
* Publisher: บงกช
* Format: multi-volumes comic set
* Language: Thai
* Book Cover: https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/image/c... (image from the publisher's website)

Note: This is a 9-volumes comic set. Each was published separately between 2008-2013 but (for some reason) share the same ISBN.


message 2: by David (new)

David Raz (davidraz) | 13269 comments I would like to follow up and get some more data before adding entry. In the future, please provide a link to the book page on the publisher's website, not to the image.
The relevant book page is this:
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
We can add the series as a single entry to the database since it is sold as a set. However, as you can see, it is not sold with the ISBN.
An alternative is to add the nine volumes, based on the publisher's website. The last one released will have the ISBN and the rest will be considered a standard ISBN reuse. Here are the relevant links:
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...
https://www.bongkoch.com/shop/index.p...

Please let us know which you prefer. By the way, you also didn't link the original material, which is here:
https://www.goodreads.com/series/363794


message 3: by Nino (new)

Nino (novemberincanada) | 74 comments I think it will be better to add all the nine volumes and consider the first eight a standard ISBN reuse, it will look cleaner on the database that way.

I didn't know what to do with books with ISBN reuse so I didn't provide the link to the relevant book pages or the original material but now that I do, I'll keep it in mind next time.


message 4: by David (new)

David Raz (davidraz) | 13269 comments I'm not a manga expert, but based on the sources I found and using Google Translate, Oyuki Konno wrote the original light novel, which was illustrated by Reine Hibiki. Satoru Nagasawa later adapted it into a manga, rewriting the text to fit the manga format and providing the illustrations. This distinction is important when determining the order of authors: the adaptor should be listed first, followed by the original author. If I'm mistaken, the entire series needs to be corrected, and I'll gladly make those changes if necessary.

ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 1
ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 2
ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 3
ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 4
ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 5
ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 6
ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 7
ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 8
ท่านมาเรียมองเราอยู่นะ 9


back to top