Timeless Pages discussion

Salt to the Sea
This topic is about Salt to the Sea
23 views
~BOTM Chats~ > July 2024 BOTM- Salt to the Sea

Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Excited about this one!!


message 2: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments I hope I'll get to join y'all this month. I have the audiobook on hold on Libby, but I have 3-4 weeks or so until I can borrow it, so I'm hoping I'll get it before the end of July.


message 3: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments I’m gonna check if the library has it and grab it next time I go if they do.


message 4: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments I just checked and it’s currently borrowed out at the library but I put a hold on it so I should get it soon.


✧Bella✧  | 1121 comments I love this book. It might be my fav by Sepetys, although I also love I Must Betray You. I put it on hold when I saw it won the poll, so I'll just have to wait for it to get to my library.


message 6: by BooksNCrannies, Co-creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 4 stars

BooksNCrannies (booksncranniesofficial) | 556 comments I read this book just two weeks ago!!! But I'm excited to join the discussion nonetheless!


message 7: by Naomi (new)

Naomi McCullough | 89 comments Our library says it has a copy, so I'll have to swing by their while I'm in town and see if it hasn't been picked up yet!


Jeremiah (Rest in peace, Charlie Kirk!!) (GFB) | 224 comments I will try to get it at my library!


message 9: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments The audiobook actually came in way sooner than it was originally supposed to, so I'll start it sometime today.


Emma Jo One of my favorite books- I am very interested to see everyone’s thoughts!


✧Bella✧  | 1121 comments The question is if I have the time to reread it.


Emma Jo I don’t think I am going to because it stays fresh in my mind, and I am in the middle of so many books, but I have never discussed it with anyone else, so I am excited to do that much!


✧Bella✧  | 1121 comments Emma Jo wrote: "I don’t think I am going to because it stays fresh in my mind, and I am in the middle of so many books, but I have never discussed it with anyone else, so I am excited to do that much!"

Yeah, I'm considering just not rereading it myself. I did place a hold on a library copy, but I've got so many library books, and I'm rereading Six of Crows.


Emma Jo I understand!


message 15: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Yay Bella, I recognize you again!


✧Bella✧  | 1121 comments Haha. I will be changing it again. Evangelise and I have agreed to do Katniss pfps sometime after the seventh. And I was considering doing another of my fav characters... But I'll always come back to either this, or something like it probably.


✧Bella✧  | 1121 comments I picked up the library copy today, but... idk if I actually have time to reread it lol.


message 18: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Bella wrote: "Haha. I will be changing it again. Evangelise and I have agreed to do Katniss pfps sometime after the seventh. And I was considering doing another of my fav characters... But I'll always come back ..."

Haha got it.


message 19: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Bella wrote: "I picked up the library copy today, but... idk if I actually have time to reread it lol."

I won’t be able to get mine until next week. It’s on hold right now and I’m waiting on it to get in.


message 20: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments I'm not sure who has started this yet, but what do y'all think of Alfred. He's really starting to annoy me...


message 21: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments I’m still waiting on it to be available at the library.


✧Bella✧  | 1121 comments I've got a library copy, but I'm not sure if I'll be reading it. Either way, I'll be able to discuss it with you all, since I've read it before.


message 23: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments Mmkay


message 24: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments I have this book now, planning on starting it soon here.


message 25: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments I read this book. I read it pretty fast so I didn't make updates or anything on it. I LOVED the book!! I did groan every time it was Albert's POV, I didn't enjoy those. lol


message 26: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Jasmine (Jazzie) wrote: "I'm not sure who has started this yet, but what do y'all think of Alfred. He's really starting to annoy me..."

Yes, he's SO annoying. What was his point in the story anyways?


message 27: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments I really don't know, tbh.


message 28: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments I'll probably post my review here sometime before this weekend.


message 29: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Was he just there to show how deceived some germans were?


message 30: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments So I have liked both Ruta Sepetys books that I've read since I learned about events I'd never heard of, and the stories are really fun. But she doesn't seem to have any character development. Her characters seem kinda two dimensional and flat. I don't know exactly what the terms mean but I feel like her books are more plot driven then character driven, maybe I'm wrong.


message 31: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments Maybe. That would make sense if that is the reason for him being there, though I have preferred it if his spot had been filled by the Shoe Poet.


message 32: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (last edited Jul 23, 2024 07:34AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Elisabeth (Bets) wrote: "So I have liked both Ruta Sepetys books that I've read since I learned about events I'd never heard of, and the stories are really fun. But she doesn't seem to have any character development. Her c..."

And I like books where I love the characters, I haven't felt attached to any characters in either of her books.

Except one character in Fountains of Silence, but he... well, let's just say things didn't go well for him. lol


message 33: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Jasmine (Jazzie) wrote: "Maybe. That would make sense if that is the reason for him being there, though I have preferred it if his spot had been filled by the Shoe Poet."

You mean the POV?


message 34: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments Yeah, I agree. I was hoping for some amazing character arcs, especially with Alfred, but it didn't happen...


message 35: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Albert was such a dummkopf.


message 36: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments Yeah, that's what I meant.


message 37: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Jasmine (Jazzie) wrote: "Yeah, I agree. I was hoping for some amazing character arcs, especially with Alfred, but it didn't happen..."

There wasn't character development in Fountains of Silence either as far as I can remember


message 38: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments I haven't read it yet, so I wouldn't know.


message 39: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments I do love her books so far tho! Just not her characters. lol


message 40: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments Wait, so his name is Albert? I thought it was Alfred.... I suppose that's what I get for listening to the audiobook.


message 41: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Oh wait, that's my bad. No it's Alfred


message 42: by Elisabeth (Bets), Creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 1208 comments Elisabeth (Bets) wrote: "Oh wait, that's my bad. No it's Alfred"

I always get those two names mixed up. We have an Albert in school and for the longest time I couldn't remember if he was Albert or Alfred, he's a year and a half old now and I finally have it down 😂


message 43: by Jasmine (Jazzie), Assistant Mod (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine (Jazzie) | 851 comments Oh, okay. You're fine, I've done the same thing multiple times before, lol.


message 44: by BooksNCrannies, Co-creator/Head Mod (new) - rated it 4 stars

BooksNCrannies (booksncranniesofficial) | 556 comments @Bets, I agree with you. I felt like there wasn't much development with the characters in Salt to the Sea. But it still was a good story. Glad you liked it!


back to top