Mock Caldecott 2026 discussion

My Lost Freedom: A Japanese American World War II Story by George Takei, illustrated by Michelle Lee




The Yellow Bus by Loren Long




My Daddy Is a Cowboy: A Picture Book by Stephanie Seales, illustrated by C. G. Esperanza




Luigi, the Spider Who Wanted to Be a Kitten by Michelle Knudsen, illustrated by Kevin Hawkes


A lot of beautiful color in this month's reading selections.

What did you think of them?

I have read and own every one of these titles. I'm a fan of each book. I do believe My Daddy is a Cowboy and The Yellow Bus have the greatest chance at a Caldecott win. My Daddy is a Cowboy is a personal favorite. Charles Esperanza creates art that is exciting, vibrant and he never forgets his audience. I'm rooting for his latest release 100%

The Yellow Bus
The vibrant yellow bus stands out against the gray background of everything else. The gray children and people who climb aboard the bus suddenly gain color themselves. This study in the life of the bus shows that when it can no longer transport people, it can at least be a shelter for others. The illustrations are beautifully executed. I also think this book has a chance for a Caldecott medal.

My Daddy Is a Cowboy
A nice story of father-daughter time together, but I thought the oil paintings were rather garish

Luigi, the Spider Who Wanted to Be a Kitten
As illustrated by Kevin Hawkes, the little spider is adorable rather than scary-looking. Sweet story, adorable spider. I don't know if that is enough for it to be considered for Caldecott consideration, however.