2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

Are Noah and Josie now in a good place? Should she tell him about her night with Luke?

This whole case revealed some serious issues in their relationship that they need to deal with. Josie should definitely tell Noah about the night spent with Luke, even if she doesn't believe she had sex with him. Noah needed to know his actions drove Josie to a very dark place.

I was very disappointed in Noah in this book. He has always been the voice of reason in their relationship and it was sad when he reacted the way he did. I expected him to withdraw but some of the things he said to her were horrible.
They do have a lot to discuss!!! Josie should tell him about Luke because if he finds out later it will be worse. Also as Anita says he needs to know exactly how he made Josie feel.

I had a hard time justifying or coming to terms with Noah’s behavior as it worsened. She didn’t deserve to be treated this way. I need more to understand why he treated her as an enemy and let his sister treat her even worse.

Josie should definitely tell him about the night with Luke. It will weigh heavily on her otherwise.

I agree with all of you. Noah needs to explain why he pushed her away so hard. He must not be totally into their relationship, which I thought he was.

Secrets always come out. Josie needs to tell Noah, and then they both need to decide whether to move forward.