The Catholic Book Club discussion

Oddsfish!
This topic is about Oddsfish!
13 views
Oddsfish! - Jan 2026 > 6. Character Connection

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by John (new)

John Seymour | 2358 comments Mod
6. Which character resonated most with you, and why?


message 2: by Jill (new)

Jill A. | 941 comments I don't find a single admirable character in this book, except the Jesuits on trial, and they are very minor characters. Oh, and maybe Roger's servant James! In particular, Roger's character gets worse as his ambition (to be a "great person") grows and he enjoys his enemies' downfall and thinks nothing of using force to get his way.


message 3: by Manuel (new) - added it

Manuel Alfonseca | 2457 comments Mod
I cannot empathize with Roger. And I find his insertion in the plot, as a fictional character, unbelievable. I cannot believe that a 21-year-old boy would be sent with so important a mission by the Pope, and would become so near to the king of England.

In particular, his being sent by the king's brother to interview the king's mistress is, in my opinion, something that would never have happened in real life.


message 4: by Marie (new) - added it

Marie Brousseau | 18 comments Jill wrote: "I don't find a single admirable character in this book, except the Jesuits on trial, and they are very minor characters. Oh, and maybe Roger's servant James! In particular, Roger's character gets w..."
Same here. I cannot find a single character I could empathize with. Everyone seems cold and calculating. I simply cannot sympathize with any of them.


back to top