Challenge Corner discussion

25 views
Feb/Mar - Yahtzee > Team Small Straight Stories - Chat!

Comments Showing 1-50 of 124 (124 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3

message 1: by Alaina (last edited Feb 10, 2026 07:58AM) (new)


message 2: by Vicki (new)

Vicki (goodreadscomboobooper49) | 5392 comments Good morning, teammates. :) Checking in!

I'm Vicki from Central Valley California, but I am currently on vacation in Hawaii. :) I love (& am addicted to) challenges. I'm a retired high school English teacher and have been so since May 2017.

I have a hubby, 5 children, 22 grandchildren, 8 great grandchildren and a Havanese two-year old dog named Daisy (aka. Crazy Daisy). I would give the names of all my grandkids & greats, but then I'll never stop talking about them and I'll write a book.

Favorite genres: historical fiction, psychological thriller, thriller, mystery and some sports romance and other romance but it's hit-and-miss.

Looking forward to playing this one!


message 3: by Lys (last edited Jan 28, 2026 02:07PM) (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments Vicki wrote: "Good morning, teammates. :) Checking in!

I'm Vicki from Central Valley California, but I am currently on vacation in Hawaii. :) I love (& am addicted to) challenges. I'm a retired high school Engl..."


Hi, Vicky! Looking forward to playing with you! How is Hawaii?

I'm Lys! I go in and out of reading and reading challenge moods, but I do really enjoy them. It's just that sometimes the internet is a very overwhelming place, and I will just abruptly disappear for a bit, so I try not to overextend myself too much.
I'm married with one 5-year-old, five annoying cats, and a sweet little hamster.

I'm coming up on a year of living in Ontario after a lifetime of living in the States. It remains to be seen whether our family will be able to stay here long term, but we're here for now.

Favorite genres: lgbtqia2s+, philosophy, fantasy, poetry, nonfiction, fluffy feel-good romance, and retellings.

Checking in, all!


message 4: by Felicia (new)

Felicia (femarie) | 680 comments Just checking in!


message 5: by Audiophile Archives (last edited Jan 28, 2026 01:52PM) (new)

Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Aloha and Howdy team! Looking forward to chat and reading with y'all.....and since this is my first time, maybe help me understand how we play this?

Do we discuss what lower section tasks we want to tackle now?


message 6: by Amanda (new)

Amanda  Edgar (amandaedgar) | 907 comments Hi everyone! Checking in :) I can send a longer intro in a bit


message 7: by Amanda (new)

Amanda  Edgar (amandaedgar) | 907 comments Oops I think the other Amanda is in this group, I'm in a different one


message 8: by Esther (new)

Esther | 1920 comments checking in


message 9: by Ashlyn (new)

Ashlyn | 6001 comments Checking in!


message 10: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments Hi everyone, checking in!


message 11: by Kim (new)

Kim | 3567 comments Hello team!


message 12: by Alaina (new)

Alaina (ameserole) | 83361 comments Mod
Got you eight checked in!


message 13: by Audiophile Archives (last edited Jan 31, 2026 07:40PM) (new)

Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Howdy! I'm trying to plan ahead (I'm doing the Zodiac challenge and we're in a frenzy trying to get the last 18 prompts/tasks done by day's end). Pulling from the Lower Section, we have a few for the team to check off:


THREE OF A KIND - Read 3 books that share one element (i.e., same setting).
FOUR OF A KIND - Read 4 books connect by a theme (i.e., found family).
FULL HOUSE - Read 3 books by the same author and 2 books by different authors in the same genre.
SMALL STRAIGHT - Read 4 books that gradually increase in page count or publication year.
LARGE STRAIGHT - Read 5 books in a single genre or series in order (i.e., #1-5, #1.5-5.5, #3-7, etc.).


some thoughts...and totally open to others sharing their thoughts:
for FULL HOUSE...can we get a list of your favorite authors? if we have a common "reader fave" that'll make picking books easier.

for LARGE STRAIGHT....any objections to romance as the MPG?

for THREE OF A KIND....any objections to set in Hawaii?


message 14: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments I read 5 books that are MPG romance in like 2 days so I'm totally okay with that lol.

I dont really read any books set in Hawaii, but if you're taking them I dont have an objection.

I can easily take the author part of Full House if we want since I'm currently working through series in a row. I'm starting with a series that has 3 books and the genre is romance if someone wants to take the other 2 in the same genre


message 15: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments Agree that romance is quick and easy.

Ambivalent about Hawaii. I don't think I read a lot set there, but I am sure I could find something interesting.

Like Amanda, I could easily help with any aspect of Full House.

Authors I read a fair bit: T. Kingfisher, Ruby Dixon, Mercedes Lackey, Maggie Stiefvater, Frederik Backman, Alix Harrow, Alexis Hall, AJ Sherwood.
Genres I am always down for: lgbtq, fantasy, poetry, nonfiction

Excited to get reading with all of you, but I have a few things to finish up before I start new for the month.


message 16: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments Oh! A good category for us might be a BOTM, right? That's an easy thread that a lot of people will be doing anyways?


message 17: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments I did not see that each book for the lower half has to be a different person, does make it a little harder.

I could definitely do T. Kingfisher for Full House author, I have an ALC so that would definitely work for me. My favorite authors are mostly indies so wont be super helpful, but can jump on where I'm needed

Genre wise I read: LGBTQIA Romance, LitFic, Fantasy

Thinking that we each have to do them, I think set in Hawaii is quite difficult, but I'd happily sit them out. If we do really want to do setting I'd suggest one of the big states if US (CA, NY, TX), or if we can do country UK, AUS, etc, or we could do a fantasy world.

For Yahtzee, any objections to using the example?

You could do the following: Books with celestial titles

EXAMPLE:
1st person reads - The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress
2nd person reads - Under the Never Sky
3rd person reads - The Sun Is Also a Star
4th person reads - The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet
5th person reads - The Starless Sea


message 18: by Vicki (last edited Feb 01, 2026 12:39PM) (new)

Vicki (goodreadscomboobooper49) | 5392 comments Hello, everyone! I have been a bit busy enjoying myself in Hawaii so I haven't "studied" our tasks. I am open to romance and Hawaii, but I don't know of any books set in Hawaii but could find one, I'm sure.

Based on msg. 13, I assume we all take part? Meaning, FULL HOUSE - Read 3 books by the same author and 2 books by different authors in the same genre (for example), 3 of us would read for that and not just one of us?

Lys, we visited Banff National Park a couple summers ago and OMG! We fell in love with the beauty of the place and the gorgeous waterfalls. I haven't been to Ontario, Canada, and I am assuming that's where you are and not Ontario, California, lol

Authors: Karen Slaughter, James Patterson, Meghan Quinn, Jennifer Armentrout, Gregg Olsen, Amy Harmon, Kristin Hannah, Ruta Sepetys, Brianna Labuskes, Kendra Elliot, Jim Butcher, Rachel Caine.

I just realized that I have many "favorite" and it's hard to pick. It depends a lot on the genre and my mood. I have one author that I love but nobody seems to know and she writes mostly historical fiction. I've loved all of her books. Her name is Paulette Mahurin.


message 19: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments I wonder if it would be easiest to have a captain or 2 and have everyone just post their books here or in the spreadsheet and then the captain(s) make decisions on where they go so we can make sure the lower half is filled out


message 20: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments setting could also be more general "a beach" or "a vacation destination"


message 21: by Vicki (new)

Vicki (goodreadscomboobooper49) | 5392 comments Lys, I like your idea of a setting being more general, such as set at/near a beach, river, or a small town, etc. It might be easier unless we do a specific state or set in Europe, possibly.


message 22: by Lys (last edited Feb 01, 2026 01:42PM) (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments These are some books that I'm planning on reading in the next week or two based on planned buddy reads and stuff I have out from the library.
Violet Thistlewaite Is Not a Villain Anymore by Emily Krempholtz The Shots You Take by Rachel Reid Time to Shine by Rachel Reid Tough Guy (Game Changers, #3) by Rachel Reid The Last Sun (The Tarot Sequence, #1) by K.D. Edwards Beartown (Beartown, #1) by Fredrik Backman Fantasy Lover (Hunter Legends, #1) by Sherrilyn Kenyon The Swan's Daughter by Roshani Chokshi My Roommate From Hell by Cale Dietrich Tourner (Ironside Academy, #2) by Jane Washington The Knight and the Moth (The Stonewater Kingdom, #1) by Rachel Gillig

and whatever else strikes my fancy.


message 23: by Vicki (last edited Feb 03, 2026 04:44PM) (new)

Vicki (goodreadscomboobooper49) | 5392 comments I can find a sports romance for sure.

Beartown (Beartown, #1) by Fredrik Backman is on my TBR
Plier (Ironside Academy, #1) by Jane Washington I wouldn't mind reading #1 of the Ironside Academy series.

Another one that might be easy is book cover color.

These are books I know I will be reading soon:

Memory Lane by Sara Shepard Desolation Ridge (Maggie Blackthorne #3) by LaVonne Griffin-Valade A Guardian and a Thief by Megha Majumdar Skylark by Paula McLain Alchemy of Secrets (Alchemy of Secrets, #1) by Stephanie Garber First-Time Caller (Heartstrings, #1) by B.K. Borison There's Always Next Year by Leah Johnson Eldest (The Inheritance Cycle, #2) by Christopher Paolini Keeper of Lost Children by Sadeqa Johnson


message 24: by Lys (last edited Feb 02, 2026 02:19AM) (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments color is a good idea!
I have wanted to read Paolini, so I am down for anything with that.


Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Lys wrote: "setting could also be more general "a beach" or "a vacation destination""

ooooooh. yes! love it.


message 26: by Audiophile Archives (last edited Feb 02, 2026 08:05AM) (new)

Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Vicki wrote: "I can find a sports romance for sure."

Yes please! I just started reading a yellow-covered sports (hockey) romance today.
Loud Mouth (Ice Knights, #3) by Avery Flynn . Tell me where you guys want this place for our challenge.


message 27: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments I also have a sports romance coming up this month for sure. That's 4 of us (Lys has two in their planned books)...we could do 4 of a kind?


message 28: by Alaina (new)

Alaina (ameserole) | 83361 comments Mod
Apologies for the delay - the teams spreadsheet has been added to message 1 on this thread.


Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Lys wrote: "Oh! A good category for us might be a BOTM, right? That's an easy thread that a lot of people will be doing anyways?"

I can do Good Girl, Bad Blood (A Good Girl's Guide to Murder, #2) by Holly Jackson this month.


message 30: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments Audiophile Archives wrote: "Lys wrote: "Oh! A good category for us might be a BOTM, right? That's an easy thread that a lot of people will be doing anyways?"

I can do Good Girl, Bad Blood (A Good Girl's Guide to Murder, #2) by Holly Jackson this month."


I am planning on reading most of them. I think I will use The Last Sun for the Yahtzee (if we do Celestial bodies>?), but I will be reading most or all (depends on how many lucky loans I get from the library)


Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Amanda wrote: "I also have a sports romance coming up this month for sure. That's 4 of us (Lys has two in their planned books)...we could do 4 of a kind?"

Sound great...I'll make sure to drop my sport romance book in the lower/4 of a kind when done.


Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments I just finished STARRY-EYED LOVE...are we doing celestial titles for YAHTZEE?

I was going to put this book #2 in series but will move it to celestial titles for now.


message 33: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments I personally think Celestial titles isn't too hard and we know it works but if anyone doesnt want to thats fine with me too!


message 34: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments Lys wrote: "Audiophile Archives wrote: "Lys wrote: "Oh! A good category for us might be a BOTM, right? That's an easy thread that a lot of people will be doing anyways?"

I can do [bookcover:Good Girl, Bad Blo..."


The Last Sun is a favorite of mine. If you want to buddy read it for extra points let me know!!


message 35: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments YES. I LOVE IT TOO. so looking forward to rereading it. ❤️


message 36: by Audiophile Archives (last edited Feb 03, 2026 02:53PM) (new)

Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Howdy! I've got these books coming up from libby hold (in 2 weeks). Anyone interested in a Buddy Read in 2 weeks?

Atlas of Unknowable Things by McCormick Templeman Storm and Fury (The Harbinger, #1) by Jennifer L. Armentrout



Wanna buddy read this with me? I can start this book about book, second chance, pen pal romance in a few days:
The Book Swap by Tessa Bickers


Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Tourist Season (The Seasons of Carnage Trilogy, #1) by Brynne Weaver

Hi, mark me down for '4/BOOK GR RATING IS BETWEEN 4 - 4.5 STARS.' I'll have it done in 2-3 days max.


message 38: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments @ Vicky, you want to read Beartown (or the trilogy) with me as a buddy read?

@Amanda, when should we do the Last Sun? It is a BOTM too, can we do BOTM AND buddy read? I didn't know that was an option. But I would totally read the trilogy with you.

I just finished
Violet Thistlewaite Is Not a Villain Anymore by Emily Krempholtz . Should I be putting it in for romance, or holding off? There's plenty of places it can fit.


Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Amanda wrote: "I wonder if it would be easiest to have a captain or 2 and have everyone just post their books here or in the spreadsheet and then the captain(s) make decisions on where they go so we can make sure..."

I love that idea. I added a tab to our ss, February_Team Notes so we can add books read/drop our notes (where it might fit; since we're undecided on Full House, etc.). It will help with year / page count, though. :D


message 40: by Vicki (new)

Vicki (goodreadscomboobooper49) | 5392 comments Lys wrote: "@ Vicky, you want to read Beartown (or the trilogy) with me as a buddy read?

@Amanda, when should we do the Last Sun? It is a BOTM too, can we do BOTM AND buddy read? I didn't know that was an opt..."


I'll read the trilogy with you unless I don't like book 1. lol


message 41: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments Lys wrote: "@ Vicky, you want to read Beartown (or the trilogy) with me as a buddy read?

@Amanda, when should we do the Last Sun? It is a BOTM too, can we do BOTM AND buddy read? I didn't know that was an opt..."


I didn't know it was a BOTM, that's more points so I think just do that :)


message 42: by Lys (last edited Feb 04, 2026 04:41AM) (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments Vicki wrote: "Lys wrote: "@ Vicky, you want to read Beartown (or the trilogy) with me as a buddy read?


OK, I will request a thread. When do you want to start?
There is a sexual assault, but it's not graphic. It's painful though, from what I remember. I was listening to the audio the first time, and it was fairly triggering.


message 43: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments Audiophile Archives wrote: "Amanda wrote: "I wonder if it would be easiest to have a captain or 2 and have everyone just post their books here or in the spreadsheet and then the captain(s) make decisions on where they go so w..."

Awesome! Thank you!


message 44: by Audiophile Archives (last edited Feb 04, 2026 06:29AM) (new)

Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments I'm reading two older books (published in 1847 and 1923), so I'll drop them in the "small straight" if that's ok?

the 1923 titles is also a buddy read: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/... ... anyone a mystery fan of Agatha Christie / Hercule Poirot? You can read any of the 30+ books in the Belgian detective series to earn us BR points.


Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments the scoreboard was just shared....just a nudge. Not only do we post our books in the ss, we also have to drop the finished book in the TSSS Review following the MOD's template...

LOL, we got the points, we just gotta let the others know.


message 46: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (bookoutbelow) | 608 comments Audiophile Archives wrote: "I'm reading two older books (published in 1847 and 1923), so I'll drop them in the "small straight" if that's ok?

the 1923 titles is also a buddy read: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/......"


Are we allowed to have 2 people read in the Small Straight? I was under the impression that it has to be 4 different people.

I'm gonna drop a 2026 book in the Small Straight for the other end


Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Amanda wrote: "Audiophile Archives wrote: "I'm reading two older books (published in 1847 and 1923), so I'll drop them in the "small straight" if that's ok?

the 1923 titles is also a buddy read: https://www.good..."


ok, removed Wuthering Heights...kept the 1923 book.


message 48: by Audiophile Archives (last edited Feb 06, 2026 09:32AM) (new)

Audiophile Archives  | 271 comments Hi, I'm reading the BOTM and hoping I can use it for our challenge. Have we decided on the lower sections prompts?

BOTM is
1) mostly red cover [if we want red covers?]
2) top 5 MPG: Mystery | Thriller | Young Adult | Mystery Thriller |
Crime
3) set in Fairfield, Connecticut USA [if we want set in US?]
4) FMC is Pippa "Pip" [if we want MC's name starts with letter P or is a female or is from UK?]
5) GR rated 4.25 (over 4) [if we want over 4 stars?]
6) published April 30, 2020 [if we want published in 2020 or April, or last day of any month?]


message 49: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments I'm also reading a BOTM, and I'm also done with it. Probably tomorrow.
I am reading Nobody's Girl A Memoir of Surviving Abuse and Fighting for Justice by Virginia Roberts Giuffre

So, if we have some other folk reading BOTM, couldn't that be a good category?


message 50: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 262 comments Audiophile Archives wrote: "Hi, I'm reading the BOTM and hoping I can use it for our challenge. Have we decided on the lower sections prompts?

BOTM is
1) mostly red cover [if we want red covers?]
2) top 5 MPG: Mystery | Thr..."


I like 3 a lot - set in a fictional place.


« previous 1 3
back to top