for the girls discussion

To All the Boys I've Loved Before (To All the Boys I've Loved Before, #1)
This topic is about To All the Boys I've Loved Before
51 views
BOTM Reading Challenge > May’s BOTM

Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

abigail elizabeth 𝜗ৎ  (God’s version) | 373 comments Mod
What are everyone’s thoughts on the book to movie adaptations??? I’m curious🤭


message 2: by zim 🎀(hiatus) (last edited May 12, 2026 01:19PM) (new) - added it

zim 🎀(hiatus) | 4 comments guyss i think i actually like the movie more than the book for this lowkey(also i've already read it but not including it in my reading challenge cuz I listened to it as an audiobook)


message 3: by sophie (new) - added it

sophie sage ✝️ i have this book in my shelf!! can’t wait to read itttt!
also, do you recommend watching the movie? and is it clean?


❤︎ abigail (semi-hiatus) ❤︎ (anastasia_c) | 64 comments sorry, which book? 😬😅


zim 🎀(hiatus) | 4 comments sophie wrote: "i have this book in my shelf!! can’t wait to read itttt!
also, do you recommend watching the movie? and is it clean?"


the movie is super good altho there are some intense kissing scenes and a bedroom kiss in the third movie thats pretty much it, considering the fact it's 13+


message 6: by sophie (new) - added it

sophie sage ✝️ @abigail: To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before by Jenny Han

@zim tysm!


message 7: by mj (new) - rated it 4 stars

mj | 3 comments i read it last summer! i’m thinking of restarting and finishing the whole trilogy.
[slight SPOILer ahead]
what do you all think of the letters?


abigail elizabeth 𝜗ৎ  (God’s version) | 373 comments Mod
@zim I completely agree! It’s perfect for young teens!!!


𝔸𝕘𝕟𝕖𝕤  | 8 comments I gotta lock in and read it!! Will I cry???


abigail elizabeth 𝜗ৎ  (God’s version) | 373 comments Mod
@Agnes probably not, but I’m not one to cry over books (I have a very short list of ones I have cried over), but who knows??? It’s just not a sad romance, but there are def some deep cuts in there🫶


ipshiii | 41 comments liked the first so much that i read all three back to back 🫣😳


Alorah Burns | 12 comments I read this book in middle school for the first time and it has stuck with me forever, it’s such an amazing book and it really reflects on teenage girls so well and is a super realistic book. Dare I say the movie was better though🫣


ipshiii | 41 comments Alorah wrote: "I read this book in middle school for the first time and it has stuck with me forever, it’s such an amazing book and it really reflects on teenage girls so well and is a super realistic book. Dare ..."


wait honestly really?? cuz i want to see the movies but i've heard a lot of hate for it and i don't want to ruin the high i got from reading the books...


abigail elizabeth 𝜗ৎ  (God’s version) | 373 comments Mod
@ipshiii WAIT- did I hear you right? You went ahead and read the whole trilogy bc you loved the first one so much??? That’s awesome!!! I’m so happy for youuuu


ipshiii | 41 comments ✨🌷Abi🌷✨ wrote: "@ipshiii WAIT- did I hear you right? You went ahead and read the whole trilogy bc you loved the first one so much??? That’s awesome!!! I’m so happy for youuuu"

yes!!!!!!! that is exactly what happened... thankyou soo much <3


abigail elizabeth &#x1d717;ৎ  (God’s version) | 373 comments Mod
And our BOTM prompted you to read it, right? Like, you hadn’t previously read it?? Bc I’m just getting rly excited about the fact that someone is actually loving and getting good recs from our BOTM, but I also want to get my facts straight😂🤭 Sorry for being so weird about it😭


message 17: by ipshiii (last edited May 26, 2026 12:47PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

ipshiii | 41 comments yesss!!!!! i did!!!! and just to point it out... all the botm's in this group have been a 5/5 for mee...sooo that says something!!!!

awww it's alrightt!!! you're not being weird.... it's really fun seeing you be this excited!!!!


and alsoo if you ever want to flex that you have amazing taste in books!! i will vouch!!!!


abigail elizabeth &#x1d717;ৎ  (God’s version) | 373 comments Mod
Aw yayyeee! I’m so glad all of these have been so good to you!!!

And tysm! I’m just so happy ppl have been enjoying our little challenges!💗🥹


quinn ೀ | 169 comments so i liked the book but i wanted lara jean and peter to end on a better note than they did


ipshiii | 41 comments quinn (laufeys version) wrote: "so i liked the book but i wanted lara jean and peter to end on a better note than they did"

girll... maybe you should move on to the second book...(just saying)


abigail elizabeth &#x1d717;ৎ  (God’s version) | 373 comments Mod
I agree😏


ipshiii | 41 comments ✨🌷Abi🌷✨ wrote: "I agree😏"

LMAOOO.....


Molly Wagandt &#x1f61c;✌️&#x1f490;&#x1f4ab;&#x1f96f; | 60 comments This book is sooooo good I just wish it wasn’t a series. Like Peter and Lara Jean should have just ended up together


abigail elizabeth &#x1d717;ৎ  (God’s version) | 373 comments Mod
@Molly so like you wish Jenny Han would have written as a stand alone and like all the conflict would have been solved by the end of the book? Bc honestly that sounds nice😂 but I think I love the trilogy too much to wish for that😂😂


Ace!&#x1f980;&#x1f3c0; | 109 comments I wish they’re was a forth. Do Peter and Lara stay tg in that first year do they marry?


back to top