Catching up on Classics (and lots more!) discussion
Book Talk
>
Possible bug in read records
date
newest »
newest »
I have 611 on my Read shelf, and there are two with a read count of 0. Both are ones where I marked it read but never entered any reading dates. That said, I have done that with dozens of books, and all the others show a read count of 1. I’m not sure what’s different about these two.
I have two that are 0, neither have read dates but another that doesn't have a date is set to 1.However i notice that the two at 0 have not date OR rating. So i think if maybe you don't date or rate it goes to zero?
...just checked add a read book with no rating, no date.. still went to 1. So seems to be a random bug.
Wreade1872 wrote: " So i think if maybe you don't date or rate it goes to zero?..."No, that is not the case. I have some books I read before Goodreads and marked read with no date and no rating. They are there with no date, no rating and a read count for 1.
I have tried sorting my read shelf after read date, and now I see a load of book that are wrong:I now have TWO copies of ถนนอำนาจ บาทวิถีคลั่ง with different “added” dates (this should not be possible). According to Goodreads I have read both. One with read count 1 and the other with 0.
I now have 7 page full of book shelfed as read but without a read date. There probably should be one or two. These books I have read recently, and are 100% sure I marked the read date:
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/4...
https://www.goodreads.com/review/edit...
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2...
Now they do not have a read date.
On top of that I have maybe 3 page full of books, I am pretty sure should have a read date, but not 100% sure.
It seems read date have disappeared in large numbers.
I used to keep a note sheet on what I read when, but stopped doing so sometime after starting to use Goodreads. I thought my notes and dates were safe here. It seems not: Books get changed and dates vanish.I have tried writing to support, but it seems that they do not read the actual content of mails. They gave me a guide to move a review from one book to another.
(original comment shortened)how frustrating, hopefully you've been doing exports regularly.
a couple of years ago I picked any random ed when the edition I read was changed for a few of my books. My reviews with book detail pages deleted have also gone, and somewhere along the line I've also noticed read dates missing. I use Storygraph more.
Recently I noticed some of the forms have changed.
Added: and now I’ve amended my reviews with ½⭐.
I believe they are working on some kind of update, since the look of some of my pages has changed. I expect everything might get back to normal once they have completed. This seems to be an ongoing thing here...gotta fix what isn't broken.
I have now written six emails to support about this. Latest reply:
Thanks for contacting us. Please provide all of the information below as soon as possible to help with the investigation:
* Are you using the Goodreads desktop site, mobile site, Android app, or iOS app?
* If you use Goodreads on multiple devices, are you seeing this error on all of the devices? Please state on which devices this is happening.
What is the software version on your device?
Click on the relevant device type for steps to find this information: computer, Android, or iOS.
* For the desktop site and mobile site: Which browser are you using, and what is the browser version?
* For the Android app and iOS app: What is the version of the Goodreads app?
Open the Goodreads app, tap More and then Settings. The version will be listed on the screen and should look something like this: Version 2.22.0 for Android or Version 4.4.1 (833) for iOS.
* When did you first experience the issue, and how often do you experience it?
* Please include direct links (URLs) to all affected pages.
* Please provide the exact steps you take before you experience this issue.
* If the Goodreads iOS app unexpectedly closed (crashed), please attach your crash logs as well.
I carefully answered all of above and here is what I got:
Thank you for your reply. For a book to count towards your current Reading Challenge, you'll need to set the Finished date (i.e. date read) to a date in the current year. Here's how to add your read dates to a book on desktop:
1. Click on My Books in the header to navigate to your shelves
(and so on)
They really are just copy-pasting random canned responses.
on the plus side, they have been busy allowing us to rate in quarter-star intervalsso there's that
seriously though JBF, and fair play to you for being so tenacious, but I gave up a long time ago trying to engage usefully with GR "support"
I just back-up all my GR data elsewhere against the day when a "last straw" breaking change happens and I tell them where they can stick my GR account.
:o(
> back-up all my GR dataThere is the library dump and the full data dump?
I just did My Books → Import and Export → Export Library
....and - you never guess - the number of records is not the same as My Books shelf.
you can request a full set of all your personal data at any time:https://help.goodreads.com/s/article/...
you get to download a bunch of zip files which have everything (book data, reviews, comments, group posts etc etc) in them (although not intuitively organised!)
J_BlueFlower wrote: "And..... I now got this:Thanks for contacting us. For security reasons I've canceled your password.
"
(original comment shortened)
I'm sorry you're going through this, thanks for posting this, it's good to know how Goodread’s Support respond to this.
Aside from Storygraph, mentioned above, there’s librarything.com, where they have their own tech team and you can also keep your entire library private. Of the book platforms I know, their book detail pages have more fields.
Not a perfect solution, and I do hope this is sorted out for you.
Where do you (any one who read this) keep track of books read? I am very much thinking about doing it somewhere else than Goodreads
J_BlueFlower wrote: “Where do you (any one who read this) keep track of books read? I am very much thinking about doing it somewhere else than Goodreads”I do it on GR, LibraryThing, StoryGraph, and BookClubs.com. They each have their own unique set of metadata that they allow. Well, BookClubs’s set isn’t unique, it’s just extremely limited.
Each of those other three will let you import your GoodReads data for a starting point.
in the spirit of "if you want something doing properly, do it yourself"I manually maintain a spreadsheet.
(and back-up several recent versions to multiple locations)
Rating and review disappeared for one of my books though the comments on the review have stayed. I only discovered it because I was revising older ratings now that half stars are allowed. I keep a back-up of reviews offline on Calibre because all my books are ebooks so I recovered my review but this is a new bug that I can't remember happening before.



I have found another altered book: I have read Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince two times. It is on the read shelf and yet the read count is zero. This should not be possible. The two read dates have been deleted.
Do you have altered books: Try go to you read shelf and sort it by read count. Do you have any with a read count of 0? (This should not be possible as read count is automatically set to 1 when adding a book to the read shelf).
I have tried contacting Goodreads Support. They are not very supportive. I got this reply “Kindly note that we do not we do not make changes on member records ... we recommend moving the review to the intended edition." (The edition I had has been deleted, and this does not addresses the problem of read dates, reviews and read counts vanishing).