Pretty Little Liars discussion

Ok seriously whos the first A? I know there is too, ive read the books but somehow ive forgotten who A was... I know no one knows who the second one is but what about the first one? Please tell me I just cant remember...

Mona was the first A.

Do you think Mona did a good job in being A? I mean she's smarter than I would have expected. I hate how she treated Hanna

I still don't think Mona was the first -A. I know that sound dumb, but maybe she knew Ali was alive and she told her the secrets. She was super smart to use the journal of Ali, but I don't think ALL of that stuff was in there. It seems too far-fetched. And yeah! She was a b**** to Hannah! But somehow, Hannah had it coming because she was a b**** to everyone else! Especially her new step-sister. I hate her.

Maybe Mona was working with Ali. But Hanna recognized Mona's number from one of A's texts, so she was at least texting them.

Yeah, i don't think Mona was ever "A" as well
i believe its another trick..from the real "A"
ahh...too confusing haha :D

Yeah i think teh real A (which really was Ali) was just playingg a mind game, but hey, who knows??

Yeah thats what i think as well :)

Brooklyn wrote: "Yeah i think teh real A (which really was Ali) was just playingg a mind game, but hey, who knows??"

(( Could you edit and place SPOILER before your comment please, some people haven't read Wanted and may not want to know that info. Thanks:) ))

Oh, sorry! :(

Nooooooo It's just some people have yet to read it. So spoilers would suck.

yea its okay but yes please dont spoil anything im only on wicked:) I'm really enjoying it so pleazz dont spoil it:)

ali's twin sister and the dude tht killed her its weird evil twin good one killed the wrong girl

Moni wrote: "ali's twin sister and the dude tht killed her its weird evil twin good one killed the wrong girl"

There was no "dude that killed her" you see.... ali had a twin sister called Courtney so Courtney changed places with Ali so the real "Ali" that befriended Spencer, Hanna, Emily, and Aria was Courtney pretending to be Ali... then the real Ali comes back and kills Courtney during the sleepover because she's mad she changed places then the real Ali comes back and preteds to be Courtney and then tells the girls she's Ali which is true but the girls didn't know that the Ali they all loved was Courtney so Ali wants revenge with them too and almost kills them but Ali really got herself killed instead ofthe girls but you're kind of left wondering if the evil Ali really died in the fire she made trying to kill spencer, hanna, emily, and aria.

But the only book that had any clues about Courtney being Ali and Ali being Courtney and the real murderer and the person who was sending the texts was the last one so you didn't need 3 other books to lead up to the end of the 2nd part. Also, the 2nd part of the 1st season of the t.v show comes out in January 2011, I can't wait. :)