Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion

I personally like both, though i like Harry Potter more, i will tell you why another time, not much time right now.

I also like both, and prefer HP quite a bit more.

cool

I like Harry Potter because of its in depth plot that just keeps getting more and more confusing, and interesting, with more characters that are flawed, and amazing. Twilight is good too... i guess.

Please check the photos to the side bar, and then vote in the polls.... please!

I also like HP for it's complex plot. I also love Jo's characters. They are more complex than Twilight's characters.

Well not all of them. You could take Neville and Carlisle, and you can't say Neville is more complex because Carlisle has way more to him than other characters.

True. But I was basically just talking about the main charcters... but I guess Neville is a main charcter, so never mind.

I like them both. I actually can't pick between them, so I won't. There are books I like better, but they're still in my top series.

I SPOUSE HARRY POTTER

why do u pick edward why OMG WTF

What? And watch the swearing.

I agree... what!? i have no idea what that means.

Me neither!! What do you mean "why do you pick edward"??

Yeah, I don't think anyone did...

nope

So...who likes George?

nope!

Oh, that's because you like Fred.

yes it is

Dork ;)

:P

harry potter.

YES!

harry potter is amazing and George for the world! :D

*me and my friend have an inside joke that i am George because i don't hear well...get it? he is missing and ear and i can't hear? XD*

anyway that ^^ is why i say George.

haha, i'm fred all the way.

I'm kind of like that. I miss a lot of conversations. But I'm George in our family, while Andy is Fred. We're twins in that way. But only in that way.

lol cool.

for me,the HP books are 4 but mostly 5star books, and the Twilight books are mostly 3 star books

twilight itself is 2, but the other three are 4
then...
hp
1-3
2-3
3-5
4-5
6-4
7-5...

more like
1-4
2-4
3-4
4-5
5-5
6-5
7-5

Twilight-
1- 3.5
2- 3
3- 4
4 havent read it
5- havent read it
Bree Tanner Book- 4

HP
1- 4
2-4
3- 4.5
4-5
(i read the last three soooo long ago i dont remember if i liked them....)

I give 5 to all Twilight books.
HP:
1-4
2-5
3-5
4-3
5-3
6-4
7-2--cause I don't like the ending.

wow...... five to all the twilight books, but 4, 5, and 3s to HP????? wow, thats just sad.... on a literary professenial view, Harry Potter is more exciting and better written than Twilight

you don't like the last book??? but it was perfectly executed!

The ending was absolutely horrid. And I can like Twilight books better than Harry Potter. I just don't like the whole third person narrative. But there's no reason to judge me based on my literary preferences.

percisely, and when Kimathy said, "more like" that ticked me off, cause she was telling me i was wrong, and that i was supposed to put that.

um, i think that what u read shows alot about what and who u r...

it doesn't really. I read Oliver twist, does that mean im a creepy orphan boy who has a series of bad things that never stop happen to me? nope.

because i read harry potter does that mean i am a magical being attending a school to defeat an evil man? duh, no.

i think he meant that the kind of story you read says things about you, doesn't mean you are that person

Andy wrote: "percisely, and when Kimathy said, "more like" that ticked me off, cause she was telling me i was wrong, and that i was supposed to put that."

i meant more like this in my opinion! :p you need to stop taking things so literally.

i'm sorry, i don't think i can...:(

aww that sucks.

it really does...

Adam wrote: "um, i think that what u read shows alot about what and who u r..."

what i meant, is that if ur favorite books are the twilight series, you can tell that they are a very girly person... or if theyre favorite book is Cirque Du Freak series, I might infer that you are a little on the dark side, but also have a light side (dark is also good)

I like Twilight..but Harry Potter beats it by a landslide.

Adam wrote: "Adam wrote: "um, i think that what u read shows alot about what and who u r..."

what i meant, is that if ur favorite books are the twilight series, you can tell that they are a very girly person..."

I'm a very dark person. . . .

GO R.V.!! XD

Well see, i like New Moon, I've loved it since i've read it. I'm not girly. My favourite books are Harry potter, but any other books like that, i hate. so it doesn't work with me.

Um...I like both book series equally. I also like the Gideon Trilogy and Vampire Kisses...and Lord of the Rings. So what does that make me???

Also, I read a ton of manga, all kinds. Like Fullmetal Alchemist to Fruits Basket...

ok, so you like those, but make fun of people who like romanse adventure like Twilight. You suck