Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion

[image error]

I don't like McGonnagall...so I'll say Esme, even though she probably wouldn't fight.

I'd say Minerva!

Go ESME!!

GO MCGONAGALL!

noppe fail to the old lady

URG!

haha

I LOVE McGonagall!! But she is pretty old, so...

true, but Esme is older

Yes, but not physically.

still

why is this even a question? McGonagall would win hands down, she is such a powerful wizard and Esme is a prat.

i don't even think i could see Esme fight....

I could. Read the Bree Tanner book and you'll see what I mean. But Yeah, I think McGonagall would win.

I want to read the Bree Tanner book!...Kimathy stop calling people prats because you don't liek them! Holy cow!

I'd go with McGonagall
(Maggie Smith)
She's awesome, and my name's Maggie Swift, so...

mcgonagall

McGonagall all the way! Go transfiguration!

!! ^_^ !!

I'm a Harry Potter fanatic! (have you heard of their theme park?)

YESYESYES I want to live there!!!

It opens on June 18th!

!! I wish I could go-- maybe sometime this summer I'll bug my parents about it or something...

LOL sooo back to subject.

:)

McGonagall is an Animagus- if in danger she could just Apparate and change, they would never find her.

Dodgegirl wrote: "I want to read the Bree Tanner book!...Kimathy stop calling people prats because you don't liek them! Holy cow!"

*like

why should I?....prat

'prat' backwards is 'tarp'
Edward is a tarp

(meaning 'prat' but 'tarp' sounds more insulting)

Ok, but Minerva would have the same smell as human and cat. so Esme could find her anyway.

Maggie wrote: "'prat' backwards is 'tarp'
Edward is a tarp"

that does sound more insulting! :P

but he's not so stop.

But yet again, he isn't a tarp, so you shouldn't call him one. He's a vampire.

no, Minerva is essentially a cat. She would smell like a cat.

no she wouldn't she would smell like Minerva, her fur would smell like her hair

??why does it matter anyway (even though you're wrong) since she'd be on the other side of the world, and where would Esme look to find her??

no edward is a prat/tarp. hes an obsessive, overprotective, stalkerish boyfriend. TEAM JACOB!

.....ok..

Um...I'm definitely Team Edward for Bella...

Yeah! Jacob is waaaay to cool fer Bella...... he's perfect for someone else that i won't mention 'cause you've never read the last book adam.

well, yes but gimme a sec...

follow this link-
http://www.goodreads.com/photo/user/2...

Adam wrote: "no edward is a prat/tarp. hes an obsessive, overprotective, stalkerish boyfriend. TEAM JACOB!"

see? i told you, he is a tarp/prat.

will do.

yay Kimathy! A fellow Team Jacob-er!

no...i am team Taylor's abs

I'm team Edward..but Jacob's cool.

They are both cool, unlike Kimathy's choices!

I am a team jacosalie-esme member. The founding member actually.