Twilight VS. Harry potter discussion

36 views
Book Discussions > Oso the guinea pig's thoughts on Harry Potter

Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Osoguineapig (new)

Osoguineapig | 2 comments I very much prefer the Harry Potter series over Twilight. The following is simply my opinion.

As well as having more developed and personified characters, I believe the Harry Potter series has a much better plot. It seems that each book in the Twilight series has an individual plot, and those plots are built off of in the next novel in the series. In the Harry Potter series, there are many twists and turns, events expanding on one and other, mysteries being shrouded and revealed, relationships developing, and so very, very much more. I think that there is way too much Twilight craze these days, and that not everyone appreciates the true genius of Harry Potter.

J.K. Rowling, I solute you.


message 2: by Andy (new)

Andy each book in the twilight series does have a different plot (they are loosely connected) but the thing is, is that that's cool. I actually love when the badguys aren't the same (but are still connected through the other badguys.


message 3: by 0rangeplants (new)

0rangeplants (bookishandhappy) | 3 comments I'll always prefer harry potter becauses i read it first and it's kinda of like nothing can ever live up to it. I'm not denying that twilight isn't good. I absoloutly loved the twilight saga and obsessed over them with everyone else when they first came out, but harry potter will always be bettetr (:


message 4: by 0rangeplants (new)

0rangeplants (bookishandhappy) | 3 comments better* :L


message 5: by Osoguineapig (new)

Osoguineapig | 2 comments Andy wrote: "each book in the twilight series does have a different plot (they are loosely connected) but the thing is, is that that's cool. I actually love when the badguys aren't the same (but are still conn..."

I understand this. Different people like differently structured plot lines


message 6: by Andy (new)

Andy Thank you Osoguineapig, this is what im saying, everyone likes different things, so when people like Kimathy say "There are mimimul good things about Twilgiht" that angers me, because it is only true to someone who dislikes is genre.


back to top