Insider to Imagination discussion

Which was better for what book?

the eragon book was alot better than the boring movie...

the beginning of the movie was depressing :(

book > movie -- harry potters 1,2, & 3
Book > movie -- Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse

eeeeewwwwwwwwwwwwwww twilight.

As much as I hate twilight and dispose the authors writing, the book was much better than the crappy exscuse for a movie.
Also
Book > Movie -- The Tale of Despereaux

^YES.

Harry Potter 3 : Book > Movie
Harry Potter 5: Book > Movie
Twilight : Book > Movie
Angels and Demons: Book > Movie
Lovely Bones: Book > Movie

Eragon: Book > Movies
Lord of the Rings: Books = Movies
P.S. I love You: Book> Movie

Lovely bones... For me book = movie
both too creepy to read and watch

Coraline:
Book < Movie

Idk, the movie seemed more to have a more developed plot than the book.

yes, but that's what made the book better, i think.

i have yet to read that book.

Book > Movie : Vampire diaries.
Well book vs tv shows really. But they got the characters all wrong :(

Ikr? VD was just all messed up. I think they should've made movies instead of the TV shows so it wouldn't be as messed up and maybe better than the books

How much do you think Lord of the Rings sticks to the books?

they stuck to them pretty OK. i mean, there were some parts of it i liked, but then again i loved the development between eowyn and aragorn. eowyn was my favourite character. :)

Hey she is one of my favorites too! I just love the part in the third movie when she kills the Witch King.

ahh, me too. although they didn't expand on her thing with faramir, another of my favourite characters.

honestly, though, aragorn was so frickin' HOT in the movies. he was supposed to be a little past his prime in the books, but it's not how i imagined him anyway. the movie aragorn suited the character better, i think.

I totally agree. I've got an older sister who has a crush on Aragorn.

ahahaha
i've got a crush on murtagh from eragon. :#)

That figures, I've seen a picture of him.

well i loved him right when he was introduced in the book, and in the movie, i was like 'oh my god oh my god IS THAT MURTAGH?! SCOOOOORE.'
yeh, the actor's pretty decent too, his name's garrett hedlund :)

LOL I act like that whenever I see someone familiar. If I could meet any guy I have a crush on, I would so faint.

haha! i know exactly how you feel.

for some reason, the actor who plays eragon reminded me of a younger verson from the guy in the mentalist

yeah, kindof... i know what you mean xD

lol

I think the movie Blood and Chocolate is better than the book. The movie has a lot more plot than the book does, which was basically 300 pages of hormone-raged teenagers.

Eww I don't like the sound of that title...

blewd! shakalaat

hm....i think i still want to read the book Garette. It has werewolve ^.^

Sam wrote: "hm....i think i still want to read the book Garette. It has werewolve ^.^"
Yep, any book with werewolves is still a good thing! :)

uh huh sure is.