The Lost Hero discussion

Same rules as other vs. This is going to get interesting. :)

Harry Potter! It's SOOOOOOOOO much better. No offense.

are we talking about books or movies

Uh.. Books... Movies? Both.

And PJO is WAY better! :P

No! PJO is just a copy! Think about it, Voldemort wanted to kill Harry because he thought he was part of the prophecy, and then in PJO, there also is a prophecy, which is a copy-off! And PJO isn't really long, while HP is usually 500-900 pages.

hmp!
Not true!
Many books are similar, but RR is not a rip off.!

yea

Thanks for the support Griffin, I am speaking the truth. (too bad I don't have charm speak, actually in RL I kinda do :))

kewl really

PJO, has demigods. OK HP has half-bloods, but there's a difference!

yea

HP has three types of wizards instead of one. HA!

Since, like the first book. It's Pure-blood, half-blood, and muggle born.

hehehe
Well, there's Roman and Greek half-bloods, and Olympians and minor gods.

yea and you dont like rr works then why you in this club

Both have magic, but different types of magic

I still like PJO, I never said that I disliked it. There both good, but I think that JK Rowling is just a little better. There both good series, ya know.

I don't even know why we're comparing them, the writing style is totally different, and when you look at them both, I'd say they're equal.

NO, not equal. PJO is better.

yea more pazzaz in PJO

Thank you Chloe. There BOTH equal. Sure they have differnet writing styles, buth they're kinda like cousins.

cousins?!

I said kinda, and just cause I like HP, you don't have to pick on me!!! :^<

sorry, but... nvm. I was just thikning random stuff.

maybe we should delet this vs.

maybe... but we could still compare main charries,
Percy vs. Harry
Annabeth vs. Hermione
Grover vs. Ron

Jason vs. Harry
Piper vs. Hermione
Leo vs. Ron

Harry is WAY older, same as Ron and Hermione. Oh yeah, you forgot Malfoy and Luke, they compare, same as Dumbledore and Chirion, and Voldemort and Kronos.

Harry starts the books at like 11 right? And finishes at... 18?
Percy starts the books at 12 and ends on his 16th b-day.
but yeah...

As books, draw. As power of the characters, PJO owns.

Have you ever thought that wizards can tranport form one place to another, when if a demigod usually uses a phone a monster tracks them? Yeah, so the danger threat for a demigod is usually 89%, when for a wizard it's usually 40%.

Griffin wrote: "are we talking about books or movies"

Well, I really like the Harry Potter movies... Percy Jackson is, I think, more of a lighter read, because it's more funny. Harry Potter's funny, but not as much. BUT I cannot believe what they did to the storyline in the PJO movie! Annabeth looks wrong, the Lotus Hotel is wrong, and don't even get me started on the Hydra! It's not even IN the first book! All in all, I love the Percy Jackson books, but I'd rather there be no movie at all than one this messed up.

But the movie made the series much more popular, it became published in my country at least partly because of it.

They didn't even start the movie the right way!

Actually I never compare book to movies, I enjoy both as an alternative versions... like I enjoy both Batman movie series.

ANNNNNNNNNNND for the PJO movie, they didn't even have Clarrise! She was a major part in the book!

And Percy's 17 in the movie, so they can't make another movie!!!!!! :(

:(

That movie is the worst. Sorry, Chris Columbus.

And they didn't do the exploding toliet scene!

The only thing they got RIGHT was the names of the characters. CHIRON IS A WHITE STALLION!

Also, I didn't know Grover had brown skin.....

I know right!

See, the movie was disapointing. Shame...

who has seen the hp movie yet it is SSSSSSOOOOO GGOOOOOOOODDDD!!!

Me!

hate the ending when he broke into the grave :(

Okay, be ready for my opinions! haha

Books vs. Books.
Uhh well, I dunno. really like both series. But I'm leaning more to Percy Jackson, I really enjoy both though.

Movie vs. Movies


Percy vs. Harry

Annabeth vs. Hermione

Grover vs. Ron

Jason vs. Harry

Piper vs. Hermione

Leo vs. Ron

PJ Movie vs. HP Movies
Harry Potter wins. UGGH THEY RUINED PERCY JACKSON MOVIE!!! AAAARRRGHH

Percy vs. Harry
Percy totally.

Annabeth vs. Hermione
Annabeth

Grover vs. Ron
Grover totally

Jason vs. Harry
Uuuu, i dunno. maybe harry?

Piper vs. Hermione
umm i'm saying hermione for now. since i know more about her that piper.

Leo vs. Ron
uuuh ron

( i accidentaly hit post on my earlier post)