The Sherlockians! discussion

What was your favorite long story?

A Study in Scarlet.

I like The Sign of the Four.

So far I like The Hound Of The Baskervilles. I haven't finished it though.

I thought you said you finished it. OH! you haven't been on Goodreads yet.

yeah. duh! :D

Wait, do y'all know each other outside of goodreads?

Connor and Emily do. I don't, though.

Connor and Emily = siblings.

Ah....that makes sense!

Ooooo I just finished reading The Sign of Four; it was amazing! It's my favorite!

I love that one! I love how Watson gets married at the end! The ending is my favorite out of all the stories.

Getting married was the only selfish thing Watson has ever done.

According to Holmes, you mean.

yup!

I thought it was sweet!

Yeah, usually those stories aren't to go awwwwwwww for, but when Watson proposed was one of the few exceptions!

No kidding! Of course, I almost cried in A Study in Scarrlette when I found out that those men had killed that girls father and had taken her away. (I'm really bad with names)

Yeah

I cried for hours on end at the end of the last memoir. I forgot what one it was....

I love The Valley of Fear. It's thrilling. And I like Douglas, since he is very smart. He even gives Sherlock correction. Besides, it's another story where Moriarty is involved.

deleted user wrote: "No kidding! Of course, I almost cried in A Study in Scarrlette when I found out that those men had killed that girls father and had taken her away. (I'm really bad with names)"

I know! It was like, sad. I was on the plane when I read it so I didn't cry, lol

A Study in Scarlet. So far:)

A Study in Scarlet. Amazing. Just amazing.

Thirding the Study in Scarlet motion.

I love how you get to meet Sherlock through Watson's eyes. It's amazing. And since it was the first one I read, it was awesome to be able to meet him at the same time as Watson.

Johanna ღ♣✽Hobbit and Proud✽♣ღ wrote: "I love how you get to meet Sherlock through Watson's eyes. It's amazing. And since it was the first one I read, it was awesome to be able to meet him at the same time as Watson."

Indeed. If you were in Sherlock's mind then the mystery would be lost because he tends to know almost everything right from the start. It would take the wonder and bewilderment out of his abilities quick as you can.

Exactly ^

Precisely ^^