Dumbledore's Army discussion

They serve as slaves and remain loyal to their masters until freed. Consist of powerful magic that even Lord Voldemort underestimated. The house elves.

Winky, Kreacher, Dobby and more.

Their stories cause tension to some, and pain to others.

How do you feel towards them? What do you think about them?

DOBBY!!

I love Dobby! I fully support S.P.E.W., but also think they should be able to choose to work if they want

DOBBY DOBBY DOBBY WHOO!!!!!

I think he's pretty sweet.

I hate the director of GOB because he totally cut out the house elves so they couldn't be in OoP and HBP.

the director for GoB is the same one for every movie

I know! Neville got the credit for Gillyweed and the RoR!

yeah!!!

i <3 dobby

why???

Isabelle wrote: "i <3 dobby"

me too

Arti wrote: "the director for GoB is the same one for every movie"

GoB? Do you and Hannah mean GoF, as in Goblet of Fire? Anyway, there have been different directors. Chris Columbus directed SS and CoS. Alfonso Cuarón directed PoA, Mike Newell did GoF, and David Yates did the remaining four.

ah

Can't believe winky wasn't in the movies? and how about when they fought to save hogwarts? how can they leave that out?

yeah, she was really important in the fourth! and when Ron said to go save them...and let them out of the kitchens. Dobby and Kreacher were the only ones...=(

Nikos~Need my Pottermore Letter! wrote: "yeah, she was really important in the fourth! and when Ron said to go save them...and let them out of the kitchens. Dobby and Kreacher were the only ones...=("

and that's how they knew about the room of requirement. Dobby took care of her there during her drunken spells. :-)

Lynn Hubbard wrote: "Can't believe winky wasn't in the movies? and how about when they fought to save hogwarts? how can they leave that out?"

so sad... :(

Dobby is the best...

2nd best

Who's the 1st?

They left the whole concept of SPEW out. Winky wasn't even mentioned. They should have made a:
PHEIHPM organization
Put House Elves In Harry Potter Movies
You also barely saw Kreacher.

1. I was upset when they left out kreachers moment in harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1. UGH.

2. You guys have to think about the cost, you know how much it cost to animate just one elf? more than a 100, 000$. Sure it's Harry Potter but that doesn't give the director an excuse to empty his pockets. Weather the yput the elves in or not people will still watch the movie, still like it, and they still get back the same amount of money they would have if they had put in the elves. Yeah they're practical thinkers, not Harry Potter fans like us (;

Extreme Panda Lover wrote: "They left the whole concept of SPEW out. Winky wasn't even mentioned. They should have made a:
PHEIHPM organization
Put House Elves In Harry Potter Movies
You also barely saw Kreacher."

lol

i support S.P.E.W.

me too

Dobby is among friends...