Never Too Old For Y.A. & N.A. Books discussion

Alice is currently with Jack but who do you want her with Jack or his brother Peter??

I want her with Peter

Jack all the way!

I like them both but I've read all of them but I went with Jack as well. Have you guys read the other three

Tough question,ooh. Jack is down to earth with a pinch of a bad boy attitude and he fights for what he wants but Peter (shaking my head) he's debinair (hope I spelled that somewhat right) he has a mean streak but its very attractive to me. He appears to be a bad boy but he's not. He's the mature one seductive and sexy. How can you decide.

Besides myself and Stephanie Myer Amanda is my favorite author I loves all of those books (My Blood Approves Series)

Yes I have read all four My Blood Approves books and also the Letters to Elise book. I still love Jack but Peter is okay now to me but I'd rather see him with someone else.

That's sooooo hard to choose because they're both amazing. I like the suave guys though, so I kind of have to go for Peter!

How is Letters to Elise is it as good as the other books. I would have to say Peter too

Letters to Elise: A Peter Townsend Novella was pretty good. Short but it gave some good background information on how Peter became a vampire and his time with Ezra. How he met and lost Elise. And a few things about how he never thought he would have another bond mate and actually told Jack bring her by and I'll show you she is not meant for me.

I love Jack!! I think he is perfect for Alice! Peter is on a different level than Alice. I liked her for the most part, but there were times I wanted to smack her for being dumb.

I love Jack but I definitely love Peter for Alice. I've read all the books and am waiting (Im) patiently for the next.

I think in the beginning of the series Jack was perfect for Alice. But, as she changed and matured through the story I think Peter is going to be who is perfect for her. (And I'm okay with that, haha. I like the whole "meant for each other" type of stories.)

Jack! Definitely. I love Peter and would love to see him happy but here's the thing. Jack found her first and although he knew it was Peter's blood that called her he (Peter) was not even interested. He wanted nothing to do with her. Jack and Alice became great friends and then got together and I personally think it should stay that way. I think Alice and Peter can be friends/in-laws but anything more than that will rip Jack apart and I don't think it's fair to him. He loves her and not just because of Peter's blood.


Peter is still hung up on Elise and would not be able to give Alice his complete heart anyway.

Jack Jack JACK!!!

^ DITTO ^ Everything Carrie said!

Jack!! In the beginning I thought Peter would be best for her, I was like "Duh! They're meant for each other!", but as the story went on I discovered that her and Jack were better because if she was really meant for Peter there wouldn't have been such a massive hesitation in the first place. Jack wouldn't have been able to take her away. Plus, Jack is just better. He's hilarious. Peter's kind of a downer. Only in a few instances do I prefer hilarious sweet vampire to suave sexy vampire, and this is one of them.

Hi , newbie

I have always wanted Peter. Sometimes Jack acts young. Peter just has something spesh. I loved Peters gift for her 18th . He just thinks differently.

Jack ATW!!

I love Jack and we all know that he truly loves Alice, but there is just something about Peter. You can tell that he cares for Alice, maybe even loves her but he's hesitant because of losing Elise. Ask yourself this, wouldn't you be scared to fall in love again if you had already loved and lost once? I choose Peter, I just can't count him out of the running yet.

Peter. No question, but I like my men mature and complicated.

I don't know what it is about Peter that just holds no appeal to me. Jack is sweet and hilarious, but really I think what makes it complicated is Alice. Because, she repeatedly chooses Jack but theres always some kind of confusion. I personally would like to see her with Jack, but Alice just keeps changing and it's never really set how she's going to act. And with her always changing, so does my opinion of who she should be with.

UGH. I hated Peter. He just ruined EVERYYYTTTHIINNNGG. Jack had my heart from the beginning <3

Shannon wrote: "UGH. I hated Peter. He just ruined EVERYYYTTTHIINNNGG. Jack had my heart from the beginning <3"

I agree! Jack really stold my heart from the minute he rescued Alice and took her to the coffee shop and programmed his number in her cell. I felt like Peter just got in the way. They were pulled toward each other but didn't even want anything to do with each other. Jack breaking the bond was best for everyone. Alice & Jack can be together. Peter can work on moving on and someday maybe get with someone.

I don't know. I really like them both and I really love them both. I think Peter is misunderstood and it breaks my heart that the first person he is able to love again is already with someone else. His story is sad. But, I love jack too and I know he really loves her too.
It is kind of a no win situation.

Jennifer wrote: "Shannon wrote: "UGH. I hated Peter. He just ruined EVERYYYTTTHIINNNGG. Jack had my heart from the beginning

I agree! Jack really stold my heart from the minute he rescued Alice and took her to th..."

I absolutely agree! Jack is the one! :)
I have loved Jack through out the whole series even when she wanted Peter I wanted Jack! Peter grew on me a bit but I have always been Team Jack and Amanda even explained that it was a mistake that Peter and Alice were bonded. It was really supposed to be Jack and Alice but since Jack died when he became a vampire it was transferred to Peter. But it was all straightened out in the end and they had something even better. They fell in-love even without the bond. They were meant to be together. Plus, like Jack once said, he saw her first and he was drawn to her from the very first moment :)
Team Jack ALL THE WAY!!!!

Technically the series isn't over. I thought there was suppose to be one more book?

There is. But she's stuck right now because of all the haters sending her all that hate mail. Really people should keep their opinions to themselves. At least if it's negative. It's her book and she has the right to write whatever she'd like. If she wants Jack and Alice together than they should be together...

I hadn't heard that, that is awful. :( I just thought it was put on hold since she has the other series (Watersong)that was picked up by a publishing agency.

Well maybe that was part of it? But it was mostly because of the hatemail and stuff...

Yeah, it's a shame that authors get all this hatemail about their characters and then it turns them off of writing about them. She's nowhere near ready to do the last book for this series yet (according to her website/blog). It's a huge bummer when there is only one book left and you can't get it.

I mean there are tons of series out there that don't go to my perfect happy place but do I send hatemail to the author because she's ruining the book for me? Heck no! I want the authors to write the way they want and what they want. I take what I get. If I don't like the end result, then it sucks to be me.

Carrie wrote: "Yeah, it's a shame that authors get all this hatemail about their characters and then it turns them off of writing about them. She's nowhere near ready to do the last book for this series yet (acc..."

Ikr? Dude your great. Lol too bad everyone isn't supportive of the story even if they don't like the ending results.... It's annoying. I want her to write the last book! :) I love Jack anyway. Lol

I am thinking about reading this series, but the only thing keeping me back is the love triangle. Most love triangles in YA books are so boring.. Is the one in this book good?

Oh Eveline. It's so good. And what makes it even better is that the whole series isn't based around the triangle. There are plot twists and action and so much more to this book. You should try it.