Harry Potter discussion

252 views
JK Rowling > New book??

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dianne (new)

Dianne (cb97) | 5 comments I think no book has ever really thwarted the popularity and awesome plot of the harry Potter series. So i figured only jk rowling could change this if she ever write a new series... Do you think it's possible for her to make a new one? Has she made hints about working on a new one?


message 2: by Julia (new)

Julia | 182 comments I wish she would have written a *good* sequel. Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, Parts 1 & 2 was the ultimate betrayal to canon and to the fandom, in my opinion.


message 3: by Macey (new)

Macey (meesamacey) I think she should leave everything as is. No more Cursed Child, no more secrets about Dumbledore, no more anything


message 4: by Macey (new)

Macey (meesamacey) You know what would be fun? Is to write a series a few years down the road and show what Hogwarts is like now. I guess she sorta did that with Cursed Child, but that sucked.


message 5: by Gabriella (new)

Gabriella (bookqueengaby) | 27 comments It would be cool if she did another generation of witches and wizards, when Harry’s kids were out of hogworts. That would really cool, in my opinion


message 6: by Julia (new)

Julia | 182 comments @Gabriella: Yes, it would be great to explore a timeline further in the future!


message 7: by Norah (new)

Norah Mazzola (norahmazz) | 22 comments Macey wrote: "I think she should leave everything as is. No more Cursed Child, no more secrets about Dumbledore, no more anything"
I think I'm with you on this one. None of the other books were as good as the ORIGINAL series.
I mean, I have to admit, Secrets of Dumbledore was kinda good, it was just hard to understand and confusing, so I'd say NO MORE!


message 8: by Orlando (new)

Orlando Soto Jr. (iamtrophy) | 26 comments I would welcome more.
Curse child I didn't like but it was ok.
Fantastic beats movies I loved especially the second Crimes of Grindlewald.

I am always down for more Wizarding World stories.

If Harry Potter fans only want HP then let them have it and read the same series over and over.
Wizarding World fans want more.... so bring it on.


message 9: by Julia (new)

Julia | 182 comments I would have been okay with more stories if they didn't contradict the original canon.
E.g. Voldemort shouldn't have a child. Time-turners can't change the past; they fulfill the timeline your future self will create. McGonagall was not yet a teacher when Newt Scamander was in school. I loved the first Fantastic Beasts movie, but as soon as the franchise created gaping plot holes, I lost interest in the new content.


message 10: by Orlando (new)

Orlando Soto Jr. (iamtrophy) | 26 comments A plot hole here and there isn’t enough to make me not want more wizarding world stories.

People will always cause human errors. So I understand this and refuse to let it overshadow the whole story.

I mean it is annoying the plot holes but….. meh.


back to top