twilight lovers! discussion

a. Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why

b. Do you like Jacob or Edward better, or do you like both

c. Describe Bella in one word

D. Do you think that the books were written well, great, or poor

e. Who introduced the Twilight books to you

f. Who's the funniest character in the saga

g. Who's your favorite couple in the Saga

H. How did you feel when Edward left Bella

I. How did you feel when Bella kissed Jacob

J. How did you feel at the wedding in Breaking Dawn

a.) I'd probably want an actual battle at the end of breaking dawn. I wanted a more exciting end for the end of the saga.
b.) Edward (only in the books)
c.) insecure?
d.) they were written well, I think.
e.) When i was in fifth grade, my friends Jordan, Katie, and Raquel:)
f.) Emmett<3 or maybe Jacob and Rosalie when they argue.
g.) Err Bella and Edward
h.) like I wanted to punch him in the face
i.) I wanted to punch HER in the face.
j.) It was sweet:)

a. hmm maybe the battle with the newborns, I would have liked to know more about it.
b. For Bella definitely Edward, but I still loved Jacob's character.
c. Impulsive
d. Well
e. My two older sisters :] about four years ago.
f. Jacob, and Emmett
g. Edward&Bella
h. Heartbroken
i. Mad bc she's meant to be with Edward, but I felt bad for Jacob at the same time.
j. I was happy during the wedding, and sad after, bc she said goodbye to her mom, and she knew it would be the last time she saw her.

a. I would say a bit longer fight scenes

b. Edward all the way! The eyes... living forever...

c. Awkward

D. Well because they connected with so many readers

e. My friend who read them and I didn't want to and then I was hooked

f. Emmett

g. Bella and Edward

H. Devastated

I. Pissed

J. Wanted to get to the honeymoon

a. I would probably cut out some of the details of the bed and the birth scene

b. I liked both characters in different ways

c. simple

d. Well

e. My best friend

f. Jacob or Rosalie

g. Alice and Jasper

h. ANGRY

i. Confused

j. one of my favorite parts of the entire book! :)

a. Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why.
I would have written more about the characters before they were bitten and in their early days.

b. Do you like Jacob or Edward better, or do you like
Team Edward when I am hot and Team Jacob when i am chilly ;)

c. Describe Bella in one word - Brave

D. Do you think that the books were written well, great, or poor
Well

e. Who introduced the Twilight books to you
Who hasn't heard of them? LOL

f. Who's the funniest character in the saga - Emmett and Rosalie

g. Who's your favorite couple in the Saga - Alice & Jasper

H. How did you feel when Edward left Bella - bummed

I. How did you feel when Bella kissed Jacob - Annoyed

J. How did you feel at the wedding in Breaking Dawn - Awesome :)

a. Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why: The Volturi getting busted by the cops, because then if Bella's father knew the truth, then he'd go after the Volturi for causing undue trouble for everyone.

b. Do you like Jacob or Edward better, or do you like both. Team Edward for life!

c. Describe Bella in one word. Smart

D. Do you think that the books were written well, great, or poor. they were good

e. Who introduced the Twilight books to you. my mom

f. Who's the funniest character in the saga. Alice

g. Who's your favorite couple in the Saga. Bella/Edward

H. How did you feel when Edward left Bella. sad

I. How did you feel when Bella kissed Jacob. angry

J. How did you feel at the wedding in Breaking Dawn. happy

a. Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why? : Maybe a bigger battle at the end. It would've been nice to have seen Felix die, I hate him. It would have been cool if Bree had lived and become a new Cullen. Something good should have come out of what Victoria did to the newborns.

b. Do you like Jacob or Edward better, or do you like both? : Well, I'm team Emmett! If I had to choose it would be Edward of coruse. Jacob is nothing but a whiner!

c. Describe Bella in one word. : Modest

D. Do you think that the books were written well, great, or poor? : Good question. There are a lot of people out there, with the education to back it up that say that they are very poorly written. I don't see it. She writes to express how people talk. And it wasn't ment to become a classic novel to be studied is schools. It's a young adult romance. I like Meyer's writing style.

e. Who introduced the Twilight books to you? : My daughter the super reader!

f. Who's the funniest character in the saga? : Oh Emmett of course, that's one of the reasons that I love him so much! But you've got to love Alice too.

g. Who's your favorite couple in the Saga? : Alice and Jasper - They are so openly in love and have such passion in taking care of each other.

H. How did you feel when Edward left Bella? : Actually, didn't bother me much. When I read them Breaking Dawn had just come out. So, I knew he'd be back if there were two more books!

I. How did you feel when Bella kissed Jacob? : Well, it kind of had to happen. She had to admit to herself that she did really love Jacob, but she loved Edward more.

J. How did you feel at the wedding in Breaking Dawn? : Like I was riding on a cloud. Ahhhhh

A. I WOULD CUT OUT BIRTH SCENE IN BREAKING DAWN
B. FOR ME IT WILL BE TEAM EDWARD FOREVER AS I LOVE HIM SO MUCH.
C. SIMPLE AND SMART
D. THEY WERE ALL WRITTEN IN SIMPLE LANGUAGE AS WE TALK SO FOR ME IT DOESN'T MATTER HOW SHE WRITE IT IS QUIET UNDERSTANDABLE AND I LOVE IT.
E. MY FRIEND
F. EMMETT AND ALICE TOO
G. ESME/CARLISLE AND OF COURSE EDWARD/BELLA
H. I FELT VERY SAD AS HE WAS NOT IN THE MOVIE AND I WATCH ALL THE MOVIE BECAUSE OF EDWARD.
I. VERY ANGRY AND SAD FOR EDWARD
J. HAPPY AND THAT WEDDING SCENE WAS AWESOME

A. I would have not let Edward break up with Bella. Then maybe New Moon would be a better book.
B. Edward because he is so romantic, and not a cry baby like Jacob.
C. Independent
D. I think that we're written quit well, but I don't think she should of decribed every little thing.
E. Two of my friends in the seventh and eighth grade. It was all they talked about, and I was tried of not knowing what they were talking about so I decided to read the series.
F. Emmett. He always makes jokes.
G. Edward and Bella of course. They amount of love they have for each is so special. Wish I could find love like that.
H. I was so upset because Edward is one of my favorite, and all the parts he is not in are boring.
I. It was nice, but I wouldn't want ot be Edward, and have to hear Jacobs thoughts while they were kissing.
J. Happy, and ful of joy. It is one of my favorite moments in the series because Edward and Bella have been waiting for this moment throughout their whole relationship. It's also a great symbol of their love.

a. Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why. i would'nt have ended it the way it ended. i would put in a fight scene in the end where the cullens destroy the voltori.

b. Do you like Jacob or Edward better, or do you like both.i like both

c. Describe Bella in one word. natural

D. Do you think that the books were written well, great, or poor. great

e. Who introduced the Twilight books to you. no one i watched the films round my friends and decided to buy the books beacause i loved the films so much.

f. Who's the funniest character in the saga.charlie

g. Who's your favorite couple in the Saga. bella and edward

H. How did you feel when Edward left Bella. upset

I. How did you feel when Bella kissed Jacob. confused

J. How did you feel at the wedding in Breaking Dawn exticed and tearfull

A. I'm not really sure...I would love to see what Edward was up to during New Moon.
B. Edward (in the books)
C. Indecisive
D. great-the actual writing is a little too "young adultish" but the way the story unfolds, builds upon itself, and all ties in at the end is what makes it a great saga.
E. No one. Went to see the first movie by myself then immediately got the books
F. Alice-she is funny in a strange Alice-way
G. Bella and Edward-is that a serious question?
H. I wanted to slap him! He should've known what it would do to her!
I. Kinda pissed at Jacob for being manipulative, and disappointed that Bella fell for it
J. I just wanted to get to the honeymoon ;) It was actually one of the only scenes in any of the movies that I liked though

a. Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why
I wouldn't have had Edward leave, but I would still ave Jacob fall in love with Bella.

b. Do you like Jacob or Edward better, or do you like both
EDWARD!!!! Jacob sucks.

c. Describe Bella in one word
Clumsy

D. Do you think that the books were written well, great, or poor
Great

e. Who introduced the Twilight books to you
My friends Alyssa and Sam.

f. Who's the funniest character in the saga
Emmett

g. Who's your favorite couple in the Saga
Edward and Bella

H. How did you feel when Edward left Bella
I was very up set. Edward is my favorite character and it hurt to see him leve.

I. How did you feel when Bella kissed Jacob
I really didn't feel anything because she was just exploring her oppisions.

J. How did you feel at the wedding in Breaking Dawn
I was full of tears of joy. It was a beautiful wedding.

Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why HAVE VICTORIA BITE IT IN THE FIRST BOOK AND LEAVE POOR RILEY ALONE OR HAVE A FINALE THAT INCLUDES SEVERAL OF THE VOLTURI GETTING KILLED INCLUDING JANE AND FELIX.

b. Do you like Jacob or Edward better, or do you like both EDWARD

c. Describe Bella in one word UNWORTHY

D. Do you think that the books were written well, great, or poor FAIRLY WELL WRITTEN

e. Who introduced the Twilight books to you SELF

f. Who's the funniest character in the saga EMMETT

g. Who's your favorite couple in the Saga EDWARD AND BELLA THEN ALICE AND JASPER

H. How did you feel when Edward left Bella DEVASTATED AND EMPTY

I. How did you feel when Bella kissed Jacob BETRAYED

J. How did you feel at the wedding in Breaking Dawn JEALOUS MOSTLY AND ALSO CONTENT

a. Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why

It would be about Edward and Bella again, they're love is just really cute and I can't let it go (even though it's finished)!

b. Do you like Jacob or Edward better, or do you like both

I like both, but I love Edward more, he is a gentleman and really cares for Bella. I like Jacob because he is funny and snarky.

c. Describe Bella in one word

Clumsy

D. Do you think that the books were written well, great, or poor

Written with great fullness.

e. Who introduced the Twilight books to you

Myself.

f. Who's the funniest character in the saga

Emmett!!

g. Who's your favorite couple in the Saga

Bella Swan & Edward Cullen

H. How did you feel when Edward left Bella

Sad...

I. How did you feel when Bella kissed Jacob

Shocked

J. How did you feel at the wedding in Breaking Dawn

Happy & Jealous

Hold_My_Heart (Formerly Narnian525) wrote: "a. Describe what you would do if Stephanie Meyer would have (even though everything is finished) asked you to re-write something in the Saga, what would it be and why

b. Do you like Jacob or Edwa..."

a. If I could, I would re-write Breaking Dawn to be only from Bella's POV, or from Edward's. I hated that Meyer switched to Jacob right when I wanted to keep up with what was happening with the pregnancy. I'd also include more dialogue about the pregnancy. There were options never discussed, arguments never presented, contradictions never challenged. I'd make Edward's mind reading descriptions consistent. In the first book, Edward we are told can read minds, as in "hear what they are thinking", but in Breaking Dawn, Edward can see Renesmee's and Alice's visions. Finally, I would add a fifth book, from Renemsee's perspective.

b. Edward for sure. Jacob is too cocky, immature and selfish.

c. Self-sacrificing.

D. From a literary perspective, I think they were written well.

e. I found out about Twilight from my friends.

f. Emmett is easily the funniest.

g. Hands down Edward and Bella

H. I was completely, utterly shocked, and then furious, and then devastated.

I. "What are you DOING? You're ENGAGED to EDWARD CULLEN!

J. I felt jubilant.