Twilight Lovers! discussion
Twilight
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jasmine
(new)
Dec 04, 2008 11:41AM
i saw twilight the first day it came out. Now i believe it when people say that the books are always better than the movies.. I say this because in the book the way that Bella shows emotion is different from Bella in the movie it is more descrptive and she is better protrayed in the book
reply
|
flag
I know what you mean, but I try really hard to treat books and movies as separate entities, and not judge one by the other. But the book is always more revealing, and brings you right into the story. It also keeps you entertained for longer. Movies (Excluding 'The Tenth Kingdom' which is like seven and a half hours long) keep you entertained for a couple of hours, and only give you the story from a third person perspective. Movies just aren't the same.
the pride and prejudice movie w. keira knightly was really good.
Mod
I liked the movie. But yes the book is a bit better because it is more detailed and more emotional. Also I wonder if they will but all that 4th book in and the whole part with having the baby.
Well, they can't just eliminate Renesme! They'll have to put her in, but they won't end up putting everything. Once they start cutting stuff out, they can't just put everything in, it wouldn't flow with the rest of the movies. It's just like in Harry Potter.
Mod
Omg, i really want to see twilight, but my mom wouldn't let me go cuz it's rated PG 13, but I'm not quite 13 yet...
Yeah...Harry Potter was really good, but the movies weren't that great...(except for the people who hadn't read the books yet! Grr...) I think that they'll stick Renesme in there somehow, but I really hope that they don't show the whole labor scene...cuz um, no offense to the people in this group or stephanie meyer, but that would look a bit disturbing in a movie...I mean, it was a wee bit disturbing in the book too...
yeah tell me about it,i just hope they don't show any sex seans ether, then i'd NEVER! be able to see it until i was like 21 or something!
Yah. You lucky, Rachel! Wait a sec- does that mean you've never seen any of the harry potter movies (even though they kinda suck)?
well she'd've been able to see the first two
Yay! i have yet to watch twilight though...And i didn't mean to insult you, i wasn't really thinking about what i was saying...
