Addicted to YA discussion

Thoughts?

I was a little disappointed with the conclusion to the Sam & Grace, Cole & Isabel saga. I wanted so much more. I'm dying to know what happens next, only I'll never know. I felt the story was left incomplete.

I didn't read this yet, I can't seem to find it anywhere!

ugh! this book i could not even finish! writing was terrible and sam sounds like a girl

just the whole series was crap i cant even believe this got published worse then fallen

Kierstin wrote: "I agree. Writing was not as great as the 1st. Ending was abrupt and I was left without that feeling of closure."

Yeah, it needed a stronger ending.

I thought that the ending was pretty good, like a cliffhanger. Maggie was showing that she didn't need to prove there was a fairytale ending by writing it.

I agree that the ending was a bit abrupt, but I didn 't mind. I still loved this book and kind of like that it didn't end with everything tied up into a neat little bow.

ya I wish they would have had a better ending I mean 3 books and the ending was like a page!

I liked the book but I got really annoyed at Isabel because she kept going on about how Sam, Cole and Grace had to come up with an idea and then got annoyed when they didn't but she didn't even try to think of an idea herself. Oh yeah and I agree that the ending was a bit abrupt.

I feel like we didn't really know where Isabelle and Cole stood at the end of the book which was pretty disappointing

I loved the books in truth and brought all three of the books for my own shelves.

I felt frustrated as well. I really wanted to know what was going to happen with all of the characters. Particularly Cole and Isabelle. I did find Sam to be sort of whiny at the end. It took me about six weeks to read it because I kept getting angry and stopping!

I loved the book. The ending was disappointing because I didn't want an end but let's see one of u guys write a better book.

I felt it was incomplete. Maybe I needed an epilogue . . .

The ending was really disappointing. I felt that it was incomplete. It was like a cliffhanger-- except, yah know, there's not another book to tell you what happens.

I read Forever a while ago, so I don't remember much but I know I loved this whole series. People always compare it to Twilight, but I liked it way more than Twilight. I also liked Maggie's style of writing a lot. If I remember correctly, I was disappointed with the ending? haha I really wish I had a better memory :/

I thought the ending was fine. It was a little abrupt, sure. But it was both sad and endearing. Cole and Isabel were going to keep in contact. Grace was going to try the cure. Love Maggie Stiefvater!

The ending wasn't very good, but on the bright side Maggie Stiefvater said she was writing a novel about Isabel and Cole. So hopefully we get more answers

Guys! I don't know if you know yet but there's going to be a fourth book! It's called Sinner and it continues Cole's story!! I'm so excited. Cole was my favorite character and I felt like he and Isabel didn't get a proper conclusion so this is perfect.

I feel like I needed an epilogue or something, for closure because I still had questions and "what if" at the end of the book...

Ifrah wrote: "Guys! I don't know if you know yet but there's going to be a fourth book! It's called Sinner and it continues Cole's story!! I'm so excited. Cole was my favorite character and I felt like he and Is..."

THERE'S GOING TO BE A FORTH?!?! I officially love you because I'm so happy I have been told this piece of information. Haha!

I thought the ending was terrible!! I felt as though it wasn't really finished and that there should've been more. I think a better ending should've been them finding a real cure and living happily ever after, but I guess for once it didn't happen that way. At least they all got to live .

So I pretty much became addicted to this series. I read the first time and second books in like a day and loved them! But when I got to reading Forever, I couldn't really get into. it sort of dragged on, and I ended up never finishing it. I feel like I should, because it was a great series, but I don't know. Does anyone like SERIOUSLY recommend that I Dinah the book? was the ending good?