The Heart discussion

6 views
The Twilight Saga > Jacob vs Edward

Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
I LOVE EDWARD!!!! What about you?


message 2: by Imogen (new)

Imogen (imogenrose97) | 114 comments yes team edward all the way. He was there first!!!!


* chocomusic *  (rashmirivgmailcom) I like edwards chracter.


message 4: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
People are calling him a stalker cuz he stares at Bella while she sleeps and they say what are the odds he doesnt stare at her while she's bathing!!! WTF, right?!!


 ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying* | 56 comments Mod
(people is referring to me)

Edward saw Bella ONCE in school and then started stalking her and watching as she slept? how is that NOT stalkerish? And he totally dictates who she should be friends with just because Jacob is a werewolf. How is that 'HOT'??? Plus, he's so needy with Bella, they have such a sappy 'perfect' in love feel it's almost gross...

BTW, I'm not team Jacob either, I'm just saving those arguments for next time


message 6: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
I do see your point. But I dunno. I just really like the book..... And I dunno why......


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

I want a wolf....it would be more fun I think


message 8: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
Wait..... Youre on team Jacob???!! Hmmmm.... That's a rare species in this group.... Would you mind if I cut you open and investigated you and...... In the process, KILL YOU???!!!


message 9: by Imogen (new)

Imogen (imogenrose97) | 114 comments haha I think that you shouldnt do that.... just yet


message 10: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
Why....


message 11: by ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying*, The Awesomely Evil One (new)

 ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying* | 56 comments Mod
Because I'm the one who's supposed to kill everyone ^^


message 12: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
No way!!! You can kill everybody BUT Peeta,Edward and Will haters. They're mine


message 13: by ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying*, The Awesomely Evil One (new)

 ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying* | 56 comments Mod
Will haters, go ahead... But Peeta and Edward haters are under my protection =w=


message 14: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
No way!!!!! I will kill those people while they sleep so that you won't be protecting them at that time!!! *evil laugh and creepy face*


* chocomusic *  (rashmirivgmailcom) Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ wrote: "People are calling him a stalker cuz he stares at Bella while she sleeps and they say what are the odds he doesnt stare at her while she's bathing!!! WTF, right?!!"

what a crazy freaking thought.


message 16: by ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying*, The Awesomely Evil One (new)

 ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying* | 56 comments Mod
It's true, how is that not being a stalker? And Stephanie Meyer is obviously extremely shallow because to her, it's obvious age doesn't matter as long as they look young, or on renesmee's case, old enough to pass for the same age as each other.


message 17: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
So what about in the Mortal Instruments where Alec dates Magnus???


message 18: by ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying*, The Awesomely Evil One (new)

 ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying* | 56 comments Mod
He does? Don't give me spoilers DX


message 19: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
You mean you haven't gotten there yet???


message 20: by ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying*, The Awesomely Evil One (new)

 ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying* | 56 comments Mod
Well I may have sorta accidentally not on purpose placed the book in a as of yet not identified place... *coughs*


message 21: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
Lol. Read it soon! The 5th book is AWESOME!!!


message 22: by ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying*, The Awesomely Evil One (new)

 ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying* | 56 comments Mod
Ok but anyway, answering the question:

Yes, that is slightly pedo-ish. BUT almost every couple in twilight has a significant age gap between the two people. Esme and Carlisle, Alice and Jasper, Edward and Bella, Jacob and Renesmee, and I can't remember the name, but also one of Jacob's friends who imprinted on a THREE YEAR OLD. Cassandra Clare at least doesn't have so many pedo couples!


message 23: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
Ok. Fine. Maybe it's a bit weird. But, if you were in love with a 50 year old, like, you'll die without him, what would you do?


message 24: by ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying*, The Awesomely Evil One (new)

 ~❤Rikka❤~ *living is just a symptom of dying* | 56 comments Mod
That's disgusting... In case you haven't noticed, we're thirteen rue...


message 25: by Rue~alwaysa1directioner~, The Crazily Random One (new)

Rue~alwaysa1directioner~ (Ruealwaysa1directioner) | 154 comments Mod
I know that I'm just saying. There's a 100% chance that it WON'T happen... But still.


back to top