A Beautiful Dark discussion

My choice would be obvious. Asher and the Resistance. While both the Resistance and the Order are controlling, I would pick the lesser of two evils. The Resistance is less controlling, and a bit more open about their manipulations. Asher, because he is a more developed character, and I've always had a thing for bad boys. Devin just got on my nerves. Skye got on them too. I was so annoyed of how she went back and forth.

Asher and the resistance. I like happygo lucky guys and i believe when something causes a construction another similar thing should be present to cause destruction to it to bring about balance.

Don't have to give this much thought - ASHER!

Yep, I'm with the Resistance and Asher. Always love the bad boys with the good hearts

I chose asher because he is sexy and rebellious and im atracted to him just like skye is! :D

Definitely Asher. Bad boy with a secret soft side.

I choose none, actually.
I don't really like Asher-and that's saying something since I usually always go for the bad boys. But that's the thing: I felt Asher is more like a player than a bad boy. My definition of a bad boy is Will Herondale from THE INFERNAL DEVICES. That's a bad boy. So, I'm with Devin, who I feel has a lot more to give up for Skye than Asher. I actually have a soft spot for Devin, and wish him the best. 'Tis the next book, I guess.

Ro wrote: "I would choose none, actually.
I didn't really like Asher-and that's saying something since I usually always go for the bad boys. But that's the thing: I felt Asher was more like a player than a ba..."

I completely agree with you. Most of the time I go for the bad boys too (Will Herondale -SWOON) but Asher just seemed to fake. I also had a soft spot for Devin.

I loved Devin, but then he was like, "STAB" so now i am like, "Uhhh.."

during the book i would of said devin but now i'm all for asher, the bad boy with a good heart

After that ending?
definitely Asher!

Sagine wrote: "Ro wrote: "I would choose none, actually.
I didn't really like Asher-and that's saying something since I usually always go for the bad boys. But that's the thing: I felt Asher was more like a playe..."

Ikr?! Devin is a cutie. ;)
Will is amazing *whispers quietly* Yet I became a Team Jem girl after CLOCKWORK PRINCE...Agh! Both guys are awesome and I just love both of 'em! But, oh God, Jem just caught my heart in CP...and WILL! *Facepalm* My heart broke for him too...the hot idiot.

Sarah wrote: "I loved Devin, but then he was like, "STAB" so now i am like, "Uhhh..""

Guess we'll have to wait until A FRACTURED LIGHT, huh? ;)
And I think things will clear up for Dev, judging by the title.
See:
A Beautiful Dark--->Dark=Asher
A Fractured Light--->Light=Devin

Ro wrote: "Sarah wrote: "I loved Devin, but then he was like, "STAB" so now i am like, "Uhhh..""

Guess we'll have to wait until A FRACTURED LIGHT, huh? ;)
And I think things will clear up for Dev, judging by..."

I hope it will. 'cause I reaally loved Devin. Still do. :)

i'm so torn! i don't think i've ever been more torn between two guy characters. I honestly want to read more scenes between all three of them. and to be honest, after some books i've read, i'll be happy as long as they all live lol.

Asher, 100% all the way. I really liked Devin during the book--Asher seemed like a player,; I hate players; Devin was all nice--but then he stabbed Skye and I was like, "What the. . .?" So Asher, all the way. I'm not for guys who stab me.
And even if Devin had a reason, maybe the Order forced him to stab her, he would really hurt somebody just because they told him to? No willpower. I think Asher would be less likely to succumb to things like that.
And lastly, hello? Devin has that crazy jealous weirdo girlfriend Raven.
Oh, plus Asher can play with fire. That is hot!!!!!!!!!

you guys should join the goup "a beautiful dark (Team Asher or Team Devon"!!

Asher all the way!! I can't wait to read the next book! :)

Asher because he seemed more real and isn't easilyu as controled as Devon. Devon's world is too messed up. They are playing god when they shouldn't be. The future changes all the time they shouldn't be messing with it.

Samantha wrote: "Asher because he seemed more real and isn't easilyu as controled as Devon. Devon's world is too messed up. They are playing god when they shouldn't be. The future changes all the time they shouldn'..."

i totally agree!

OH AND BY THE WAY!! TEAM ASHER ALL THE FRIGGIN WAY!!<3

ASHER

Okay, I'm way more complicated. I mean, i was all for Devin before he decided to stab Skye just because the Order ordered him to. He seemed so sweet and honest. But just to clarify, i was never for the order. I Was hoping that somehow Devin could leave the Order and be with Skye happy and with the rebellion.. but noo! Devin had to go screw up my already screwed up plans..! But, anyway, i really am not sure who i would choose at his point, i mean.. i still want Devin to be the good guy in all of this... some how.

Sarah wrote: "I loved Devin, but then he was like, "STAB" so now i am like, "Uhhh..""

Yes! that is exactly what i'm saying. I am totally rofl ryte now!!!

Zaria wrote: "Okay, I'm way more complicated. I mean, i was all for Devin before he decided to stab Skye just because the Order ordered him to. He seemed so sweet and honest. But just to clarify, i was never for..."

LOL. Even with the stab-thing, I prefer Devin to Asher. I do hope that the author will surprise us with Devin and his choices in the next book. Who knows? Maybe Devin will join the rebellion in later time. So, I agree with you. :) Go Devin~!

Okay don't get me wrong here, because after reading A Beautiful Dark I totally liked Asher more. Even though he tried to kill her, I still have a soft spot for Devin. And then I read A Fractured Light and Asher did nothing wrong in this. But I am totally Team Devin even though I have a terrible feeling she'll choose Asher. Finger crossed, Devin fans...

Okay, I am always found of the good boys if they are as sexy as i think but in this book im going with the hot dark mysterious dude well because the good guy stabbed "the one and only"

Asher......then. Nope, still Asher!!

Is it bad if I say neither. They both are too overly flawed. We don't see enough of their good sides. The two guys are ALWAYS fighting with eachother and I feel like we never see any good qualities in either of them.
I'm going to say Ian.

I have to say Asher for this one. Devin is cute and all but I can't believe he plunged a knife at Skye. I don't really like the Order because I don't like to take orders from people. I want to be in the Resistance.

Sarah wrote: "I loved Devin, but then he was like, "STAB" so now i am like, "Uhhh..""

Exactly how I feel haha I hope that something happens in the next book that changes what he did!

Asher. He was sent to convince Skye to join the Resistance and Devin was sent to kill her. I was Team Devin at first but by the end of the book, I went for Asher.

I don't like this boook. So i dont give a shit!

i would pick asher but i am slightly conflicted between them... dont know why tho...

At first I picked Devin because I'm kinda stupid when it comes with good guys but as I progressed through the book, my mind started wandering where to go between Asher and Devin. Devin was trusted but he ruined it because he's a goody toshu but Asher was absolutely, incredibly worthy for Skye so Team Asher.

THE RESISTANCE

I like just started reading the first book.......and i am like on the 5th chapter, but still, I choose Asher. I mean i love bad boy types and he is just really funny....so Team Asher!!!!!!

I totally think that asher is hot and I almost always go for the bad boys but I would really rather have devin..........and even though he betrayed her I still love him and forgive him in the name of LOVE!! :)

I'm going all the way with Asher and what was the resistance because all I know are the Order, the Rebellion, Rogues and the Uprising.Team Skasher!