The Not-So Austen Bookclub discussion

These two! Friends. Enemies. Rivals. Allies. Brothers-in-arms. They are my two fave guy characters when it comes to fey fiction and I dedicate this area to all things Ash and Puck.

If anyone has read Iron Knight, and the interview at the back!, my fave part was when Julie says she would live with Ash and Meghan in the Iron Realm, only because you can't find a wireless signal in the wyldwood! :D

that part was funny! in iron knight i think that in the end they sort make up where they left off before ariela died.

oh i love these two!!!! ..ah ash*grinning like an idiot*
i loved how she ended it with Ash and Meghan together and with Ash and Puck friends again! i just hope in her spinoff Puck gets some romance!;)

I totally love Ash. I'm so obsessed with him.
Like I said somewhere else, I have a thing with battle-scarred, hardened heroes that seem cold outside and act like the bad guys but are, in fact, the good ones and just have a lot of pain hidden inside. They just need someone who can understand them and lots of love.
I would be more than happy if I could be the one giving Ash the love he needs xD
Puck, well, I used to like him because he was Meghan's "protector" but after I found out that he basically led to Ariella's death, leaving Ash to pain without end, I could no longer keep thinking the same.
Also, I didn't like when he was tempted to betray Ash to Titania so he could be killed and he could keep Meghan to himself.

Lucy wrote: "I have a thing with battle-scarred, hardened heroes that seem cold outside and act like the bad guys but are, in fact, the good ones and just have a lot of pain hidden inside. They just need someone who can understand them and lots of love."

can't agree more. and I can say: same here.. I like that u r thinking deep, beyond the obvious coldness in a person/character. there's always some secret, something hidden.. just waiting for the right person to uncover it!! :) :)

As for Ash: no matter how many books I read, and how many other character I get to know, Ash will always be my favorite. A real knight (and we miss real knights these days!). I love guys who take care of the ones they love.

Puck: A great best friend. Always there. And despite everything that's happened (what with Ariella and Meghan) well, it's hard to hate him.

Becca wrote: "Lucy wrote: "I have a thing with battle-scarred, hardened heroes that seem cold outside and act like the bad guys but are, in fact, the good ones and just have a lot of pain hidden inside. They ju..."

Thanks! You are totally right. There is always something behind the coldness. Some deep pain that no one knows about and if they do, that no one understands.

Becca wrote: "As for Ash: no matter how many books I read, and how many other character I get to know, Ash will always be my favorite. A real knight (and we miss real knights these days!). I love guys who take c..."

Indeed!! I couldn't agree more as well :)
The one and only knight in my heart is Ash +.+
We need knights these days...

Becca wrote: "As for Ash: no matter how many books I read, and how many other character I get to know, Ash will always be my favorite. A real knight (and we miss real knights these days!). I love guys who take c..."

Couldn't agree more! :)
i'd like a knight like Ash..;)

Becca wrote: "Puck: A great best friend. Always there. And despite everything that's happened (what with Ariella and Meghan) well, it's hard to hate him."

i love puck! i hope in the spin off series he finds love!

Ok, I absolutely love Ash. Puck on the other hand..... not so much. He's not too bad of a guy but what annoys me is how he complained about Meggie and Ash when he could have gone out with Meggie was before Ash came along

I love both, but when it comes to Meghan, i am Team ASH. But Puck and Meghan kinda good.. but awkward

Kristi wrote: "Ok, I absolutely love Ash. Puck on the other hand..... not so much. He's not too bad of a guy but what annoys me is how he complained about Meggie and Ash when he could have gone out with Meggie wa..."

I am Ash all the way, but Puck feared rejection, which is what he got for waiting so long.

i love ash! he is soo good for meghan as she can melt his frozen heart, and puck, while he is funny, he just doesn't go well with meggie like ash does

I am 100% in love with Ash! But Puck is great and I hope he finds love in the spin-offs!

I love Puck!!! But I love Ash too!!!