Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion

17 views
Debates > ACTUAL-Debate 1

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Bookgeek_zah, De Head Mod (+_+) (new)

Bookgeek_zah | 42 comments Mod
Hi everyone, welcome to the debate! Our topic is that the Harry Potter series is better than twilight saga.
I would like three members who agree to present their case followed by the negative team.

Sequence:
person for, person against, person for, person against, person for, person against.


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
what happens if you like both?


message 3: by Bookgeek_zah, De Head Mod (+_+) (new)

Bookgeek_zah | 42 comments Mod
Give opinions for both.


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
ok


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
Harry potter is about more than romance, i like books that have adventure, action, fantasy and romance, yes , but romance not being the major genre! Harry potter got me reading in the middle of the night (this book was the reason i started reading books at night) even though my neck got caught once from doing that :/ i couldn't move :/..um...i went through a lot with this series (like getting grounded 'cause i was reading it at night XP) and it has hidden details that only by reading it for a second time would i have noticed


message 6: by Bookgeek_zah, De Head Mod (+_+) (new)

Bookgeek_zah | 42 comments Mod
I believe that Harry Potter clearly beats any modern vampire/ werewolves folklore series.
Harry Potter is a fantastic protagonist in the series, having his ups and downs but always living up to his heroic duty. Not only does this series have an amazing plot but it is also very advanced in literary terms. In twilight however almost a third of the first book is description and poetic remarks regarding Bella or Edward. Is this the type of modern literature that should be well-known, to us young adults?


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
(i though you said for then against? in that woredr?)


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
(*thought)


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
(*order)


message 10: by Bookgeek_zah, De Head Mod (+_+) (new)

Bookgeek_zah | 42 comments Mod
Yeah, well it seemed nobody was going to contribute.


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
ok....

Twilight is the first romance book i've ever read and the frist book i've ever read with vamps and werewolves. I really like the way it was written, as though YOU were bella.

also i hated the fact that...after like a week bella and ed start dateing and she already wants to 'vamp' herself to be with him forever and after only a few month (in new moon) she starts getting depressed over a person that has put her in danger and she geos all zombie just 'cause of a guy sshe met in less than a year before, THEN she falls in love with jacob ..ugh don't get me started! then renesme... firstly, who calls their kid after both yours and your lovers name?! seriously?!


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

(All good reasons :D)


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
(:D)


message 14: by Maria (new)

Maria (Maryaha) I love harry potter, always had but I just hate the movies. They're so different from the books.

I like twilight but it's really cliché.
Normally I would say a lot but I'm in a kind of hurry :b


message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

I love Harry Potter too, ever since I read the first book. The movies are okay, but they can't compare to the awesome books.

Twilight is okay, but it's a bit to mainstream for me, and the movies are a little overrated sometimes.


ᑕᗢᗝᒪḰᓮᖙᖇᗢჯ123 ☆*・゜゚・*\(^O^)/*・゜゚・*☆ Cool (coolkidrox123) | 38 comments Mod
kristen stewert rewined the movies


message 17: by Steven (new)

Steven | 1 comments Coolkidrox123 {If you read my name you will die} wrote: "kristen stewert rewined the movies"

Agreed!


message 18: by Serena (new)

Serena I havent rly read any of the harry potter series YET (i will soon) but i love the twilight series to me because im such a lover of vamp/human relationships for sum reason and i think her devotion to edward is so inspiring in everyday relationships it shows that if u give the dedication anyone can be happy


back to top