Freedom Readers discussion

discussion 4

I actually really liked the creativity of this book. To think that the idea just came from one person's idea is commendable. Suzanne Collins is a fantastic writer. Also, Katnisss may be a fantasy of what she wishes she was.

i think the ending of the hunger games is very good for a series. if it was the only book and there were no sequels then it might be to brief. it nicely raps up the current thread of the story and putws some suspence toward the next book. it finishes the games themselvs but it shows how they are still not save.

Noelle wrote: "I actually really liked the creativity of this book. To think that the idea just came from one person's idea is commendable. Suzanne Collins is a fantastic writer. Also, Katnisss may be a fantasy o..."

well when you think of it almost all books ideas come from one persons mind. i to like the creativity but all books are from one person.

Justin wrote: "i think the ending of the hunger games is very good for a series. if it was the only book and there were no sequels then it might be to brief. it nicely raps up the current thread of the story an..."

It is a nice twist... But, for the love they show, it was kind of expected.

I would not change anything about the books ending. It leaves you wondering what the next book will bring. Also it promises a next book.

i think the book was pretty good. the ending surprised me but it was probably worth it to read the whole entire book.

Justin wrote: "Noelle wrote: "I actually really liked the creativity of this book. To think that the idea just came from one person's idea is commendable. Suzanne Collins is a fantastic writer. Also, Katnisss may..."

I do know that, although this idea was particularly interesting due to the idea of children put on TV to kill eachother.

Mason wrote: "I would not change anything about the books ending. It leaves you wondering what the next book will bring. Also it promises a next book."

i can agree with that, i do not realy see how to improve the ending, if it whent into district 12 the ending may seem to abrupt.

I kinda liked the book but other wise it was probably my favorite book I read. I didnt like how most of the begining of the book was boring but then it got better towards the end.

i did think the ending was pretty good. i liked how the mutts were the tributes that died became the them. i liked how they made them a team so they wouldnt have to kill each othere. then at the end also they swiched it up again and told them had to be one winner. then they out smarted the capital with the berries

Dan wrote: "i think the book was pretty good. the ending surprised me but it was probably worth it to read the whole entire book."i think the endiong was very suprising and got swiched up alot

I really liked the ending of the book. It left the reader content, instead of leaving us with a massive cliff hanger. I hate cliff-hangers. I completely followed the emotions of both Peeta and Katniss after they left the Capitol, and felt terrible for both of them, and their dilemma. The one part of the ending that was a bit strange was when Katniss thought 'The most dangerous part of the Games has just begun'. After I read that sentence, I looked at how much I had left to read... Maybe thirty pages? I was kind of skeptical that Collins could cram a REALLY dangerous encounter with the Capitol, while at the same time, making sure the book had a decent ending... In thirty pages. :) Good book. I'd read it a third time, if I didn't have others planned!

Ilike the book a lot. and it was relly cool wine thaey fiet. and the ending i was not a big fane of. but i woed raet the book 4 stares. and i am gowing to read the nets one.

Mason wrote: "I would not change anything about the books ending. It leaves you wondering what the next book will bring. Also it promises a next book."i atgree i figured there was going to be another book

Mason wrote: "I would not change anything about the books ending. It leaves you wondering what the next book will bring. Also it promises a next book."

i woued read the nets one if i was you.

I believe the ending of the book was very good because the book was very descriptional. My favorite part was when they held out the poison berries infront of the capitol so they could both win the games. I have started to read the secound book and that plays a big part in the plot. I would not change one thing in the entire book. The description that the author gave was very good, the entire book was also well writen. I would give it a 10 out of 10 stars.

Justin wrote: "Noelle wrote: "I actually really liked the creativity of this book. To think that the idea just came from one person's idea is commendable. Suzanne Collins is a fantastic writer. Also, Katnisss may..."

i did not exsped it at the end

Garrett wrote: "Mason wrote: "I would not change anything about the books ending. It leaves you wondering what the next book will bring. Also it promises a next book."

i woued read the nets one if i was you."

i agree with gmoney, it might just be more interesting

Justin wrote: "i think the ending of the hunger games is very good for a series. if it was the only book and there were no sequels then it might be to brief. it nicely raps up the current thread of the story an..."

I agree the end left you hanging for the secound book.

Mason wrote: "I really liked the ending of the book. It left the reader content, instead of leaving us with a massive cliff hanger. I hate cliff-hangers. I completely followed the emotions of both Peeta and Katn..."

i agree, the ending was good yet interesting.

The end of the Hunger Games was very different then what some people would expect. I have been thinking,what is the main reason why the author wrote this book. What was she thinking of while writing this and what is the reason of this book. Anyway this book is one of my high recommendations to people beacuse it is great.

Justin wrote: "i think the ending of the hunger games is very good for a series. if it was the only book and there were no sequels then it might be to brief. it nicely raps up the current thread of the story an..."

If there were not a sequal then there would be a tragety and few people would like it

Justin wrote: "i think the ending of the hunger games is very good for a series. if it was the only book and there were no sequels then it might be to brief. it nicely raps up the current thread of the story an..."

I agree! I like that they tie up the Games, realize that they're still in danger, and totally mess up their relationship with each other. It has a sense of finality, while everything is still hectic and screwy.

Justin wrote: "i think the ending of the hunger games is very good for a series. if it was the only book and there were no sequels then it might be to brief. it nicely raps up the current thread of the story an..."


I agree with your thought about how if there were no more sequels that it would be to brief

Noelle wrote: "I actually really liked the creativity of this book. To think that the idea just came from one person's idea is commendable. Suzanne Collins is a fantastic writer. Also, Katnisss may be a fantasy o..."

One of the main things I thought about, is this how Suzanne Collins thought of herself trapped like Katniss.

Justin wrote: "i think the ending of the hunger games is very good for a series. if it was the only book and there were no sequels then it might be to brief. it nicely raps up the current thread of the story an..."

Without the rest of the series the Hinger Games would not be nearly as good.

Garrett wrote: "Ilike the book a lot. and it was relly cool wine thaey fiet. and the ending i was not a big fane of. but i woed raet the book 4 stares. and i am gowing to read the nets one."

i liked the book alot too, I am in the process of reading the secound one.

Garrett wrote: "Ilike the book a lot. and it was relly cool wine thaey fiet. and the ending i was not a big fane of. but i woed raet the book 4 stares. and i am gowing to read the nets one."

I also thought it was cool when the fought in the arena.

I think that the books ending was good. The thing i would change would be to make the book shorter and only have the action part towards the begining. I thought the book was good at the end but the begining was painful. I would rate the book at a B- or a C+ just becasue the begining wasnt to well. I thought the cliff hanger it left you at was pretty extreme.

Mike wrote: "I kinda liked the book but other wise it was probably my favorite book I read. I didnt like how most of the begining of the book was boring but then it got better towards the end."
the beging is aguably the most importent part take that away and the book makes no sense

Justin wrote: "Noelle wrote: "I actually really liked the creativity of this book. To think that the idea just came from one person's idea is commendable. Suzanne Collins is a fantastic writer. Also, Katnisss may..."

Noelle wrote: "I actually really liked the creativity of this book. To think that the idea just came from one person's idea is commendable. Suzanne Collins is a fantastic writer. Also, Katnisss may be a fantasy o..."

Justin wrote: "Mason wrote: "I would not change anything about the books ending. It leaves you wondering what the next book will bring. Also it promises a next book."

i can agree with that, i do not realy see..."

Not necessarily... Erin Hunter, the writer of the Warriors series, is a pen name for three people... They pool their creative abilities, and crank out a couple books a year. I think THG could have been improved a bit... I really didn't like how Peeta lost his leg. It seemed like a minor injury, compared to what could have happened. Collins was probably trying to show that they didn't get out unscathed but... seriously? I dunno. It just seems like a fact they really could've done without.

Noelle wrote: "I actually really liked the creativity of this book. To think that the idea just came from one person's idea is commendable. Suzanne Collins is a fantastic writer. Also, Katnisss may be a fantasy o..."

i think the writer was smart as a whip when all this happen. Katnis is really cool and precise with the bow

Luke wrote: "I believe the ending of the book was very good because the book was very descriptional. My favorite part was when they held out the poison berries infront of the capitol so they could both win the ..."

in my opinion i would give it an 8 out of 10 because of the begining which was really non descripful and boring but the end made up for it