The Face on the Milk Carton (Janie Johnson, #1) The Face on the Milk Carton question


136 views
I have a theory (sort of)
Michelle Michelle May 07, 2012 07:47PM
After reading this book a thought struck me. I'm thinking what if Janie really belonged to the Springs (which I think is true) and when they were in that mall Hannah was there too and she saw Jennie and realized that if her parents will have another child to take care of then she'll be free and be able to live with the so-called cult of hers.

So.. Hannah is the one who kidnapped Jennie Springs. (I think)

Any thoughts?



100000000000000000000000 stars.


There are more books to this series (just in case you didn't know).


Pretty good theory. I have read the other 2. do not want to spoil it ,but you could write at least book 2.


This book was boring and had no action. One star.


Accutally negative five stars.


Nathaly (last edited Jun 24, 2013 12:52PM ) Jun 24, 2013 12:42PM   0 votes
I gave this book 1 star. waste of time


Mason, you are wrong. These books are incredible.


They're not supposed to be a action books. All my friends I had given the books to loved them.


Michelle wrote: "After reading this book a thought struck me. I'm thinking what if Janie really belonged to the Springs (which I think is true) and when they were in that mall Hannah was there too and she saw Jenni..."

My original theory was that she kidnapped her so she could give her parents a second chance at raising a child.

16596817
Bonzi Reads i loved this book
Sep 17, 2014 02:41PM · flag
F 25x33
Kate Georgia: I'm not sure why Hannah would care about that. I saw Hannah's motivations differently. The last book in the series, Janie Face to Face, sheds ...more
Jan 07, 2017 07:25PM · flag

This book was so poorly written, I can't even believe it got published. Mason, you are so so so correct. Negative five stars is a definite!!


i read this as a teen in foster care and LOVED it and then one of my best friends read it and love it. We were thirteen.


I'm not sure if you guys know this but it's a series. I thought that it was pretty good.


back to top