Harry Potter discussion

What is the craziest what if u can think of?

Here's mine-
What if.... Harry was never the Chosen One? Instead the prophecy chose Neville?

Christina Mugiwara Inductee Russ wrote: "What if Voldemort turned out to be Harry's biological father whom Lily had an affair with at some point in the past?"

ha ha ha! i love that idea!

What if Ron never had a sister? Means no Ginny.

What is Tom Riddle never became Lord Voldemort

Then the whole book would be meaningless and nobody would read it. It would not sell and J. K. Rowling would never have been a billionaire and would have been wondering... If only I had made him evil. LOL!
But thank God that's not the case and she has made him a wonderful villain.

What if..... Snape had used the time turner and Invisibilty cloak and returned back to the orphanage where Voldemort was and killed him.

What if Harry hadn't sat next to Ron on the train the first day?

Ishani wrote: "Then the whole book would be meaningless and nobody would read it. It would not sell and J. K. Rowling would never have been a billionaire and would have been wondering... If only I had made him ev..."

On youtube there's this thing on what should of happened in the deathly hallows and that's what happened!

What if Lily chose Severus instead of James? ( he was her friend before she met James!)

Candycloud wrote: "Ishani wrote: "Then the whole book would be meaningless and nobody would read it. It would not sell and J. K. Rowling would never have been a billionaire and would have been wondering... If only I ..."

Yeah I know! The How it Should Have Ended Videos are awesome!
Really liked the Deathly Hallows ending...

Ishani wrote: "Then the whole book would be meaningless and nobody would read it. It would not sell and J. K. Rowling would never have been a billionaire and would have been wondering... If only I had made him ev..."

No,he had become minster of magic and controlled power in other way

This is like a game. I didn't make it clear when I posted the discussion though. But u r supposed to answer each What If and then post urs!

LET'S START AGAIN,.....

What if Snape had been never been a double agent?

Ishani wrote: "Candycloud wrote: "Ishani wrote: "Then the whole book would be meaningless and nobody would read it. It would not sell and J. K. Rowling would never have been a billionaire and would have been wond..."

Yeah, I love them too! Lol, they're so funny, me and my bff Poppy were laughing so hard when we watched on of them, I can't remember which though...

To Ishani: Which one would he just be working for? Voldomort or Dumbledore? Or do you mean no agent at all for either?

What if Petunia was a witch instead of Lily?

Reading wrote: "To Ishani: Which one would he just be working for? Voldomort or Dumbledore? Or do you mean no agent at all for either?"

Either one. It wouldn't matter much.

Duplowaffla wrote: "What if Petunia was a witch instead of Lily?"

Do you think Dudley would have been a wizard instead of Harry?

Lets see.... Um...
Harry wld still have had a family.

What if Hermione's parents had been wizards?

To Ishani: It would have been terrible if Dudley was a wizard! Dudley is afraid of everything magic and not as courageous and brave as Harry. Plus, he probably would have become best mates with Draco, Crabbe and Goyle which would mean Voldemort may never have been defeated...

Ishani wrote: "Lets see.... Um...
Harry wld still have had a family.

What if Hermione's parents had been wizards?"

She would be the best pupil who ever had been in hogwarts in all subjects, I guess.

What if Harry and Hermione would fall in love?

Ron wld still be the side kick and Ginny wld be ithe backlight.

What if Voldemort's mother was alive?

She would probably join him, despite her old age, by acting as a spy for him.
Even though I think that at first she wouldn't agree with her son, but having gotten over her heartbreak with Tom Ridfle Sr, it would kill her to go against her son.

What if Draco had been in Hufflepuff?

*Riddle, sorry!

I don't think the Malfoys would accept this. Their whole family has been in Slytherin. Besides even if Malfoy was Hufflepuff he wld still be as stereotypical as he is because the changing of house won't change his family values or blood status.

What if U got a Hogwarts letter?

*just peed in pants at the thought of it* 'nough said

What if Harry killed snape before snape could kill dumbledore?

Dumbledore would've given him a good smack in the head for messing up the plan.

What if Dumbledore had allowed young Aunt Petunia into Hogwarts after she wrote her letter?

She wouldn't be able to learn magic, being a Muggle and all, but her relationship with Lily would have been less tarnished.

What if Harry Potter died for real in the last book?

Then the hogwarts students would be heart broken but would carry out Harry's original plan
What if this book took place somewhere else?

Like in another country?

Yep like the U.S.

Hmm… then start imagining all of the characters with American accents!!!

What if harry and ginny didn't get married?!?

Then Ginny would get together with Neville ...

What if Harry never found the Mirror of Erised in the first place in the first book?

A sudden cheese storm would have killed Voldemort.

What if there was no such thing as Hogwarts?

Harry would be a halucinater
What if harry and Ron hadn't locked the troll in the girls bathroom

The troll would travel around the school, trying to stuff the goblet of fire in its mouth xD

What if Hermione had married DRACO MALFOY?!?!?

There would be a lot of ronimione series on YouTube
What if harry was in slytherin

He would probably be the same person.

What if Draco was in Gryffindor?

His father would hear about it
What if voldemort had died in the first book

Then the Wizarding world would rest in peace (not in the dead way)

What if Voldemort had a kid?

He wouldn't last long around the new wizarding world
What if the durselys died

Harry would be a free wizard.

What if there was no such person as Harry Potter?

Then there would have been no such book as Harry Potter, no famous jkr, no 1 million fans all across and life wouldn't hv been complete.

What if JKR wrote another book after her Casual Vacancy?

She will continue her Harry Potter series

What if Harry and Draco are twins?

There would be more hate between them
What if snape survived

He would take Harry as his child
What if Harry was Voldemort's reincarnation lover?

Bellatrix would kill both of them most definitely!

What if Dumbledore told everyone that he was in love with Grindelwald?

Didn't he already do that:)
What if S.P.E.W had never exsisted

It would have been a very sad and different ending to the series...

What if..Ron never came back after leaving during their trip to find Horcrux's?

The friendship would never be the same between the Trio.

What if Voldemort had chosen Neville to obsess over for seventeen years?

Harry and his family would just be another regular family..and he might not be as close to Ron and Hermione...

What if there was no feud between Draco and the trio?