Deanna was very black, very round, very beautiful, and even though I adored the younger one I got by blood, Deanna was also the big sister I’d always wanted to have.
I sat on my thoughts about this one damn sentence for a full week and half. I couldn’t move forward in the book because I had to figure out what possible context could it mean and why she felt it necessary to even include the description “very black”. I came up empty regarding its purpose in describing Deanna and my level of offense hasn’t changed over time. I don’t think the author was being intentional malicious, but as a black woman, the entire sentence felt like a backhanded compliment. It’s disheartening that no one on her beta team and/or editing team at least paused at that sentence and asked “why is this even in here?”. But alas it is, and this author has the right to write what she wants, but I don’t have to read it. So, this is where I exit stage left with this book and this author.
“There was only one Mama, and the world has lost her, but it keeps turning. But for me, I live in that void where her love and her voice and her kindness used to be. And in so many ways, even moving forward, I’m standing still. I am suddenly aware of everyone’s compassion, this collective kindness for which I was unprepared. It penetrates the wall I use to insulate my grief and hide the lingering pain. I hate that these tears keep assaulting me when I least expect them. That sadness ambushes me. That the desolation Mama’s absence creates inside of me is inescapable, even here at Thanksgiving dinner in front of Rhyson’s family before we’ve even served dessert. And I hate this awkward quiet while they all try to figure out if it’s okay to move on or if they wait for me to get it together. Only this time I can’t. I’m trapped in this moment while I reach for my composure in vain. Breathing in and deeply usually helps, but I’m too far gone. My heart is too raw today. A sob erupts into the silence. I’m horrified that my body is betraying me this way. That my emotions are this undisciplined, wet spill over my cheeks. I squeeze the linen napkin in my lap until I’m sure I’ll draw blood from it, but the tears won’t stop. The pain doesn’t stop. I leak it. I lose it. I cannot stop it. I cover my face with”
― My Soul to Keep
― My Soul to Keep
Ask Philippa Gregory
— 865 members
— last activity Apr 30, 2024 12:00PM
Here's your opportunity to have your questions answered by queen of historical fiction, Philippa Gregory. Philippa will be answering your questions ab ...more
The Perks Of Being A Book Addict
— 37409 members
— last activity 18 minutes ago
This group is for anyone who loves books from different genres. Every month we have group Books of the Month which you can join, reading challenges, a ...more
Romance Readers Reading Challenges
— 21999 members
— last activity 18 minutes ago
If you love to read romance novels, or just read, and you like reading challenges, come and join this group. If you look at your TBR list and don't kn ...more
Harry Potter
— 17190 members
— last activity 4 hours, 18 min ago
We're fans of Rowling's series because we know that it is more than just a children's fantasy story. ...more
New Adult Book Club
— 20200 members
— last activity Mar 25, 2026 11:55AM
This group is for everyone to share their love of New Adult fiction - the rapidly growing catagory for books that have the same coming of age feel as ...more
April’s 2025 Year in Books
Take a look at April’s Year in Books, including some fun facts about their reading.
More friends…
Polls voted on by April
Lists liked by April









![Midnight Sun [2008 Draft] by Stephenie Meyer Midnight Sun [2008 Draft] by Stephenie Meyer](https://s.gr-assets.com/assets/nophoto/book/50x75-1b903c9eac1b2ba789662c08a0ae41e6.png)

















































