Abbey > Recent Status Updates

Yellowfang ;__; also this section (and this book in general) was written really well. Them evacuating the fire reminds me of the fear of waiting out a hurricane in the dark when you have no idea what will happen to you or your house.

The fire is the only thing I remembered about this book so I've been kind of dreading it (said in a lighthearted way, but it's sad).

Aagaghgg I just want to keep reading because big things are happening but I have other responsibilities. Btw the metaphors/similes/imagery in this book are beautiful. I keep writing them down for inspiration.

Cloudpaw :( just yesterday I wanted to look up the painting of him on the cover to see if I could find the full thing, but I didn't because of spoilers, and I'm really glad I didn't! I wonder if he comes back?

Also it was funny that Fireheart was so oblivious to Sandstorm's interest in him. Everyone in the clan except him knew!

I'm still trying to get over the fact that Cinderpelt was renamed between books.

Lots of interesting things are happening and it's paced nicely. I wish I didn't already know that Cloudpaw had gone to eat kittypet food, but it was still surprising that he happily went into a house. Will he ever learn??? The way Sandstorm encourages him to let Cloudpaw decide for himself reminds me of myself watching my brother make poor decisions. Also there's a lot of great descriptions and metaphors. Summer<3

AHHH!!!! ITS GETTING CRAZY. Seeing Fireheart and Tigerclaw fight after building up their rivalry for 3 books was so satisfying. HE TOLD THEM EVERYTHING!!! And Tigerclaw WILL be back (said w fear). also the line "I'm going to kill you, and kill you again. As many times as it takes for you to join StarClan forever. It's time for *me* to lead this clan!" is SO METAL. Also he wanted to make thunderclan great again LOL

The pacing in this book is SO much better than Fire & Ice. The long travels to and from meeting Ravenpaw were just cut out! Wow! It's not like the journey to find WindClan that felt long and sometimes confusing and repetitive.

I wish I didn't already know the truth about Oakheart's kits because that would make the truth much more shocking when it's revealed later. The search to find the truth is really interesting!

I'm glad the recaps are over fast lol. I already know about oakheart x bluestar, but I'm very intrigued by the way it's slowly being revealed 👀

Unfortunately my library only has the new cover for this one. I feel like these don't capture the atmosphere like the originals do. Those tell stories and match the titles really well! I do like the new chapter illustrations though.

Idk how much of this is just because I'm reading more, but I think it's stopped dragging now that I've gotten to silverstream, cinderpaw, and now princess's kit :) there's still a little bit of unclear imagery and odd dialogue, but it's a lot better than before. Something is actually happening

It was dragging for a long time. A lot of reviews said it got bad when silverstream was introduced, but between her and cinderpaw, it feels like something is finally happening again 😳💀

It feels like it took a while to get going. Explanations of characters and events from the first book (because I guess some people didn't read that one?) took me out of the story. And then for a while fireheart and graystripe were just walking in silence and it's describing things a lot but I sometimes can't tell what I'm supposed to be seeing :/ it also goes by fast at the same time, and I'm sure it'll get better.

Very interesting so far! I just want to keep reading it. I love how descriptive Oscar Wilde is. I didn't think a story with mostly dialogue (so far, at least) could be so interesting. It also seems very gay.