*Buzzfeed Unsolved voice* Now, let's get into the theories:
- Helen is the most sus, I think. My prime suspect, definitely. From what Tanner noted, I guess, it's possible that she was pretending to be Martin in some of "his" correspondence.
- Martin is oddly cold to James. Maybe that's not his bio son?
- Isabel must have known before that Sam died. It's possible she's the killer too, but not AS likely, I think.
— Sep 23, 2026 11:59AM
Add a comment